I like my ob/gyn practice in West Orange. They're called Women First and it's 3 doctors: Claudine Sylvester, Sonya Youngren and Dr. Mansuria. They are affiliated with St. Barnabas. I can try to find their phone number if you want it. They're right next to the high school in West Orange, sort of behind the Whole Foods/KMart complex. You could also look into the Avalon midwife practice, I think they're in Caldwell.
mama to H. 4/05 and A. 9/08 and baby C. 10/11