Mothering Forums - Reply to Topic

Thread: Paraguard reviews - Mirena vs. Paragard IUD Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Drag and Drop File Upload
Drag files here to attach!
Upload Progress: 0
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the Mothering Forums forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
User Name:
If you do not want to register, fill this field only and the name will be used as user name for your post.
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.
Password:
Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.
Email Address:

Log-in

Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.



  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
06-25-2014 11:34 AM
justmommie08
Quote:
Originally Posted by julie128 View Post
<p>I have a Paragard (non-homonal IUD), which I used to be quite happy with. However, I have been bleeding off and on for going on two weeks now, no cramping. My new doc put me on the mini pill to stop the bleeding, but it might take the full four weeks to stop. Has anyone used both types of IUD? Would taking out the Paragard and putting in the Mirena help? Did you like one better than the other? Thanks</p>
I had paragard removed after 11 months because I was bleeding for 20 days at a time. It was more of an annoyance than an issue, according to my doctor who checked it twice before I finally had it removed. After it was removed I only had 10 days, but most of that was pre and post CM and not actual period. It was fine other than the annoyance of going through a box of supplies every month!
06-01-2014 12:47 PM
LexiFred I also use extra caution around my ovulation time. My boyfriend and I use the pull-out method around ovulation time (5 days before ovulation, three days after) even with Paragard. Just incase!
05-21-2014 01:24 PM
beckymock

I have had both Paraguard and Mirena, I liked Mirena due to not having my monthy after the first year but had to replace it when my son was 5 Yrs old, the clinic paid for the Paraguard. I'm not sure if the Paraguard is the cause for my yeast infection that I always have.

04-24-2014 05:30 PM
natashag08 Hi everyone, I have had the mirena before and have the para guard now. I love the para guard I have had it over a year now! I do have a little heavier bleeding and cramping during my cycle but not longer. Me personal would never get the mirena again I had it for like 4 months and hated it. I had hair loss, acne, leg pains, pains in my pelvic, And I felt like I was always hungry. I would not recommend to anyone. I have a few friends that tried it to and did not like it either.
04-22-2014 02:16 PM
Beautiful4
Quote:
Originally Posted by alpiner84 View Post
 

Hi everyone,

 

I'm replying to this topic just to get some more info out there about switching from Mirena to Paragard.  When I swapped mine out, I couldn't find much information about it.  

 

In short, it's been way easier than I thought it would be.  I expected a few months of cramps, irregular bleeding, horrendous periods, etc, and got absolutely none of that.  

 

The switch itself was practically painless; "sounding" my uterus was more painful than either the removal or insertion.  No bleeding, no cramping, and I was totally fine within minutes of the procedure.  

 

Tried sex the next night, and it was uncomfortable whenever he came in contact with my cervix.  A few days later sex was completely fine/comfortable.

 

First period came on the full moon instead of the new moon.  It was a very normal period, just like it used to be in the days before I went on hormonal bc:  average PMS with one big ol' cramp, followed by a five-day period.  It was pretty darn light compared to all the horror stories, just minipads most days, two days of regular tampons every 12 hours or so. 

 

Two weeks later, when ovulating, I had the most incredible libido.  Seriously, I couldn't fall asleep one night because I was thinking about sex so much.  I think I wore my man out that week ;-)

 

Second period came exactly 28 days after the first one, full moon again.  Same as before, slightly heavier flow on day 3, but no cramps when PMSing.  

 

I was going to wait three cycles before posting, but I'm excited to let everyone know that switching from the Mirena to the Paragard has been a breeze for me!  I switched over because of dietary concerns--I think the hormones were aggravating my IBS.  So far I haven't noticed any changes in my digestion, but at least hormones aren't part of my "what's wrong with me" equation anymore.  And I'm baby-proof for ten years--awesome. 

 

Good luck!

THANKS SO MUCH FOR THIS POST!!! YOU JUST HELPED MAKE MY DECISION CONCRETE!!!!!

04-22-2014 11:43 AM
Beautiful4
Quote:
Originally Posted by tarablesue View Post

I had the Mirena for 7 months and it made me psychcotic. I had thoughts of hurting m,y kids and that they'd be better off if I weren't their mama. It was awful. I had never had any depression before either.

I have the Paragard , well have had it for 3 months, and my period cramps are AWFUL. I hate it but I really don't think I have another option for BC. I can't have failure. I just can't. I have been told the cramping gets better, so I guess I am holding out until it does. If it doesn't then I'll cross that bridge when I get there.

I personlly wouldn't opt for Mirena, I have never beenin that place before and after being that low I don't want to go back. Had i not did research, even my OB thought I was crazy that it was the Mirena, I might be dead or even worse, in jail for hurting one of my kids. IT was really THAT bad, for me.

Tarablesue...Wow this is years old off the topic of the mirena but the same thing you experienced with the mirena as far as the psychotic behavior I experienced that with the implanon.  You have helped me to decide on just getting the paragard.

04-22-2014 11:40 AM
Beautiful4

Tarablesue...Wow this is years old off the topic of the mirena but the same thing you experienced with the mirena as far as the psychotic behavior I experienced that with the implanon.  You have helped me to decide on just getting the paranard.

02-06-2014 05:19 PM
odalisque

I loved my Paragard for the year I had it. My periods were heavier and cramps were worse but it was completely manageable. Unfortunately I had an ectopic pregnancy with the IUD that ruptured and I had to have surgery. Thankfully I got to keep my tube and ovary. This is a rare complication but I think everyone should be aware that it can happen. Pretty upsetting, because I really did like the IUD, but I will never feel comfortable relying on it again.

01-20-2014 07:47 PM
alpiner84

Hi everyone,

 

I'm replying to this topic just to get some more info out there about switching from Mirena to Paragard.  When I swapped mine out, I couldn't find much information about it.  

 

In short, it's been way easier than I thought it would be.  I expected a few months of cramps, irregular bleeding, horrendous periods, etc, and got absolutely none of that.  

 

The switch itself was practically painless; "sounding" my uterus was more painful than either the removal or insertion.  No bleeding, no cramping, and I was totally fine within minutes of the procedure.  

 

Tried sex the next night, and it was uncomfortable whenever he came in contact with my cervix.  A few days later sex was completely fine/comfortable.

 

First period came on the full moon instead of the new moon.  It was a very normal period, just like it used to be in the days before I went on hormonal bc:  average PMS with one big ol' cramp, followed by a five-day period.  It was pretty darn light compared to all the horror stories, just minipads most days, two days of regular tampons every 12 hours or so. 

 

Two weeks later, when ovulating, I had the most incredible libido.  Seriously, I couldn't fall asleep one night because I was thinking about sex so much.  I think I wore my man out that week ;-)

 

Second period came exactly 28 days after the first one, full moon again.  Same as before, slightly heavier flow on day 3, but no cramps when PMSing.  

 

I was going to wait three cycles before posting, but I'm excited to let everyone know that switching from the Mirena to the Paragard has been a breeze for me!  I switched over because of dietary concerns--I think the hormones were aggravating my IBS.  So far I haven't noticed any changes in my digestion, but at least hormones aren't part of my "what's wrong with me" equation anymore.  And I'm baby-proof for ten years--awesome. 

 

Good luck!

01-14-2014 12:51 AM
conscience mom I had mirena for 5yrs and my experience was good until the day I had it removed and replaced with paragard. I wasn't really for another child so I got an new IUD. Ever since then, I have so many problem with my stomach. I don't know if the problem derived from the removal of the mirena because the day I had the procedure done, I was in so much pain. Or the problems derived from the paragard. I have derived ulcer in my stomach in these two year period. I'm having longer period circle, more than five days. I have decided to get the paragard removed no more birth control for me. I did the shot before and it was giving me heart burns.
01-08-2014 08:16 PM
alynn6213 I have had the paraguard for about 6 months. I got it at about 5wks pp. I HATE IT! I've had nothing but trouble. It was painful to have inserted. I immediately had a VERY heavy period and have continued to have extremely heavy periods and spotting constantly. I've also been on meds for pH issues 4 times since I got it. My bf can feel it and complains about it. I have not been right since I got it and I'm seriously considering having it removed at my annual in a couple of weeks. Not sure what to try next. On top of that, insurance didn't cover most of it so I'm still paying for it. Chose the paraguard over Mirena because of the hormones because I was BFing but this has been a nightmare! greensad.gif
12-29-2013 09:57 PM
polgar I have had the paraguard for 6 yrs & loved it. Love the no hormones, love that I know to the day when my cycle will start & I am used to the heavy periods that typically only last for 4 days. Until this month. I have had a cycle for most of the month. Not sure why after all these years why this is happening to me now. Has this happen to anyone else?
12-09-2013 04:37 PM
hmoss84
Quote:
Originally Posted by julie128 View Post

I have a Paragard (non-homonal IUD), which I used to be quite happy with. However, I have been bleeding off and on for going on two weeks now, no cramping. My new doc put me on the mini pill to stop the bleeding, but it might take the full four weeks to stop. Has anyone used both types of IUD? Would taking out the Paragard and putting in the Mirena help? Did you like one better than the other? Thanks
I have used both. I had a mirena for about a year but had it taken out bc of constant pelvic pain and infection. Decided to try paraguard and I've had it for two weeks and have not stopped bleeding. I spotted for months on mirena but this is not spotting this is a full period, heavy bleeding cramps and all. I don't know if I should wait it out or get it taken out. Any advice?
11-04-2013 02:46 PM
Shelly C

I've had my mirena in now for about 6-7 months and i'm considering having it removed. I was losing weight when I had it inserted and building muscle, but since it's insertion i've gained 5-6 pounds which I can't lose, but worse of all it's ALL fat, no muscle, which is ridiculous considering I do olympic weightlifting as a sport. I had it put it because I was having quite a lot of PMT prior... but i'm seriously thinking it's time to give it the flick. I've also had to be on the mini pill to stop break through bleeding as well... so don't think it's for me.

11-02-2013 05:05 PM
jorly
Quote:
Originally Posted by keeks211 View Post
 

Hello All!

 

I would first like to thank everyone who has contributed their experiences to this thread, it has been SO helpful.

 

I am 21 years old, have never had a child, and have struggled with several types of BC in the past.  I've determined that my body does not do well with the extra hormones (hate the mood swings, lack of sex drive, and since I'm a professional ballet dancer, the extra weight gain and swollen, tender breasts are a HUGE problem!).  I was on Ocella (generic of Yaz) for a few years with a few extra pounds I couldn't seem to shake, and have recently stopped taking Lo Loestrin Fe after 2 months (my boobs grew 2 cup sizes and hurt like HECK, I cry for no reason, and my sex drive is completely gone).  I'm too paranoid for condoms alone and my period isn't regular enough to track my cycle.

 

I was thinking of getting an IUD, and after reading most of this thread (still haven't made it all the way through yet, but planning to!), I have completely ruled out the Mirena.  No more hormones for me!  So now I'm left with Paragard.  It seems like it may be the best option, but with the heavy periods and the fact that I dance in pink tights for a living, it might not be a very good fit. Also, the risk of infertility and/or unplanned pregnancy with Paragard in place terrifies me, since my boyfriend and I want to have children at some point, but NOT right now! I don't want to kill my chances of having children someday :(  HELP! 

 

That got a bit wordy, but does any one have any advice as to what they think I should do?  I have an appt with my OBGYN Thursday (7/18) to talk about Paragard, but I'm afraid she will try to convince me to get the Mirena or try a different pill, when I know that I am DONE with those awful hormones! I just want some suggestions from real women who have actual used these things!!!  Thank you for any advice you might have!!!


Hi, I am interested if you decided to get Paragard? I just got off of Lo Loestrin Fe because of side effects like moodiness and feeling anxious. Thanks!

11-02-2013 05:02 PM
jorly

Hi,

I am interested to find out if you got Paragard and how you like it? I also was on Lo Loestrin Fe but just recently got off because of mood swings and feeling anxious. Thanks!

10-20-2013 11:06 AM
lockegirl75 I have the mirena have had it for seven months. It's ok I don't feel quite like myself not sure if its due to the iud or just being tired because I'm a full time sahm ,I feel i get irritated so easy never did before. I cant say ive gained any weight. I do get a lot of back pain which i believe is one of the side affects get very light periods in a yr I will see how I feel and if I'm still feeling the same out it will come. Hopefully then I will feel like myself
10-20-2013 09:07 AM
Katie8681 Oh gosh, spotting after mirena can last for up to 6 months. But by a year, many women don't have periods at all.
10-19-2013 04:07 PM
Skippy918 It's been a little over a week and I thought the spotting was done, but it came back this morning.
10-16-2013 07:03 AM
Ratchet Spotting can be for a while- at least a week for a lot of people. What were you on for birth control before the mirena? If it was pills or depo or something else hormonal, it probably prevented the migraines (often there's a hormonal trigger that pills etc block). I first found out I had migraines when I stopped pills (after taking them since age 15), which coincides with when I started mirena, but for me I'm certain the mirena wasn't the cause. Migraines continue now without mirena, and when I had paragard too.

OBs don't always know a lot about migraines (except how they relate to pills etc) so it might be better to talk to a primary care person about it (if you haven't yet)
10-14-2013 07:36 AM
Skippy918 I'm hoping someone here has advice. I just got the Mirena last Wednesday. On Saturday I came down with a migraine which has not completely cleared up yet. I have never been in this much pain before and the nausea was really bad. I threw up a few times. I called the doctor and felt like my concerns were dismissed and whoever I talked to said my headaches were not related to the Mirena. I'm also bleeding on and off even though my period is supposed to be done.
How long did you bleed/spot for after insertion? Thanks!
10-10-2013 11:19 AM
Katie8681 Updating- 2 happy years with paragard. No side effects, not pregnant. Yay!
10-10-2013 07:16 AM
Ratchet Sorry
10-06-2013 07:31 PM
Woolgirl Ratchet,
I understand that research shows the mirena is effective for 7 years, but when I start to bleed again and my doctor tells me that it could be the hormone being released is lessening, I think it is wise to heed her advice and replace it. Or should I just leave it in the 7 years because that's how long it's worked for you?
We need to listen to our bodies.
10-04-2013 05:05 PM
Ratchet Birth control pills will probably lessen libido because it blocks ovulation. Lots of research shows the mirena is effective for 7 years, that's how long I had mine
10-02-2013 07:23 PM
Woolgirl I have had the Mirena for 5+ years and am ready to have it removed/replaced. I should mention I'm done having children. I really had no negative side effects. I have to say I have Loved the fact that my periods got lighter and lighter until pretty much none at all. Until recently when I started to bleed randomly every other week or so. I went in to ask my doc about it and she said it could very well be that because it's been 5+ years the hormone it releases is getting "low." Essentially it is losing it's effectiveness, which is why I'm experiencing mini periods again. I also noticed lately that my libido is through the roof, in comparison to normal. It occurred to me, the fact that this coincided with the periods coming back, makes me wonder if the Mirena actually lessened my libido and I didn't realize it until it came back! Which I'm enjoying. Now I'm on the fence about whether to just have it removed and use a different birth control, or have it replaced and possibly lose my libido. I'm bummed having to make this decision!
10-02-2013 01:18 PM
mmm1618 After reading all of these how many are reporting longer, heavier periods, that sounds wonderful to me compared to what I've been through. I've been on my second implanon for a year. The first one did give me trouble, and I got a second one because I was still under 18 and my mom just wanted me to be protected. I hate bleeding constantly an heavy bleeding at that every day. I've been taking mini pills a long with my implanon. I just want to not worry. My normal period was 5 days of heavy bleeding. I'd be okay with a little longer. At least no one reports of heavy bleeding everyday from IUD because it's just the worst to go through no ends of bleeding. So hopefully when I try IUD, it works out for me.
09-22-2013 05:42 AM
JenniferGr

I have had the Mirena for 18 months. Getting it out next week and going to try the Paragard.

Was on the pill before and thought an IUD would be easier.  I have had too many side effects,would rather

go back to the pill. My headaches have increased and my breasts hurt all the time and I've gained weight

that I can't lose.  I don't recommend the Mirena for anyone who has not had children or have headaches,

migraines. I hope the Paragard, without the hormones, will be better.  

09-08-2013 08:27 AM
martitac

Hi everyone!!I was just reading some of the comments and decided to tell my experience with Paragard. I am not a mother yet but I do have paragard and it's been quite hectic with my period.I used to have only two short days of heavy bleeding in total four day of my regular period.But since paragard I have had very heavy bleeding and it last for 10 to 12 days..!!if that helps anyone to make a decicion to which birth control works better please think carefully. On the other had, I know that every system and body works differently ..but with Paragard you definitely will have to deal will the never ending periods!!Good Luck and I  think I will try Mirena and see!! If any one could give me an advise about Mirena that will be great!Thanks in advance!!

:)

08-24-2013 09:54 AM
Ratchet Gator girl- I also had migraines that started when I got mirena-- BUT it was because the birth control pills (and nuva ring) i was on before were preventing them. I had the mirena x 7 yrs, the nothing for a while, then a paragard, and the migraines continued. Basically, any method that does not stop ovulation will let me have migraines. So not the Mirena's fault.
This thread has more than 30 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off