Mothering Forums - Reply to Topic

Thread: breastmilk isn't vegan Reply to Thread
Title:
Message:
Drag and Drop File Upload
Drag files here to attach!
Upload Progress: 0
Trackback:
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:
 

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the Mothering Forums forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
User Name:
If you do not want to register, fill this field only and the name will be used as user name for your post.
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.
Password:
Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.
Email Address:

Log-in

Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.



  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

  Topic Review (Newest First)
07-05-2014 08:38 PM
Viola
Quote:
Originally Posted by blessedwithboys View Post
I always had the impression that veganism was less a diet and more a philosophy of life. In other words, I had the idea that people practice veganism out of respect for other creatures. Thus, not using leather products, lanolin, or honey.
If you read vegan literature, that's pretty much what it says. I think if you are claiming to raise your child as a vegan, that means your child is more or less following the same dietary practices with the idea if you raise him with these beliefs, he may choose it for himself when he is able.
07-05-2014 04:59 AM
JamieCatheryn
Quote:
Originally Posted by BlessedOne View Post
yes it is no surprise cows in a large scale industry are bred as frequent as possible (and possibly altered by hormones or steroids) to produce more milk, although the way the poster made it sound, was it was a very small scale farm situation. But even so, calf gestation is about 9 months and typically only one cow born at a time (twins are only about 3% of the time). So with all of that being said, a cow that is not overly bred, should be able to have a relatively normal nursing routine. But here is the problem....most large scale cow factories (and maybe even some smaller ones) will take the calf from the mother anywhere from immediately to the first couple of days. So therefore she can not nurse her young, but instead have her milk stolen, while her calf is on a powdered milk replacer.
I didn't mean frequency of freshening (pregnancy) for the cow I meant genetic adaptation, they bred the cows that gave the most milk for so many generations that dairy cows give a lot of milk. Family dairy cows kept with their calves make an extra 1-2 gallons a day.
07-02-2014 06:44 PM
blessedwithboys Pardon the intrusion... I am SO not a vegan but am 100% lactivist through and through, so I'm gonna take a chance here and reply.

I always had the impression that veganism was less a diet and more a philosophy of life. In other words, I had the idea that people practice veganism out of respect for other creatures. Thus, not using leather products, lanolin, or honey.

So if respect for living things is at the core of veganism, how could human milk ever be anything BUT vegan?! The baby isn't taking something without permission, the milk is freely given.
07-02-2014 03:52 PM
Viola
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adeptus42 View Post
Breast milk is NOT vegan.
Breastmilk is vegan. The reason you should care is because there are certain people who, falling into this thinking that it isn't vegan because it is produced by the human animal, decide to feed their children soy formula instead, thinking somehow they aren't allowed to breastfeed. This makes no sense.

Do I care if it's vegan or not? No. But people try to make the irrational argument that if you're doing something that isn't vegan, like feeding your children your milk, then you can't be a vegan. That's like people telling me I'm not really a Christian because I don't believe the same things they do.
07-02-2014 03:32 PM
BlessedOne yes it is no surprise cows in a large scale industry are bred as frequent as possible (and possibly altered by hormones or steroids) to produce more milk, although the way the poster made it sound, was it was a very small scale farm situation. But even so, calf gestation is about 9 months and typically only one cow born at a time (twins are only about 3% of the time). So with all of that being said, a cow that is not overly bred, should be able to have a relatively normal nursing routine. But here is the problem....most large scale cow factories (and maybe even some smaller ones) will take the calf from the mother anywhere from immediately to the first couple of days. So therefore she can not nurse her young, but instead have her milk stolen, while her calf is on a powdered milk replacer.
07-02-2014 08:05 AM
tadamsmar You could use Zaphod's argument in this quote for Restaurant at the End of the Universe:

Quote:
'You mean this animal actually wants us to eat it?' whispered
Trillian to Ford.

'Me?' said Ford, with a glazed look in his eyes, 'I don't mean
anything.'

'That's absolutely horrible,' exclaimed Arthur, 'the most revolting
thing I've ever heard.'

'What's the problem Earthman?' said Zaphod, now transfering his
attention to the animal's enormous rump.

'I just don't want to eat an animal that's standing there
inviting me to,' said Arthur, 'It's heartless.'

'Better than eating an animal that doesn't want to be
eaten,' said Zaphod.

'That's not the point,' Arthur protested. Then he thought about it
for a moment. 'Alright,' he said, 'maybe it is the point. I don't
care, I'm not going to think about it now. I'll just ... er ... I
think I'll just have a green salad,' he muttered.
http://www.saunalahti.fi/~huuhilo/dna2.html

07-01-2014 05:27 AM
sillysapling Strictly speaking, it's true. Humans ARE animals. Human milk is an animal product. If they're suggesting that you should stop breastfeeding- they're idiots. But they may object to you using a term they don't agree she fits, which I can understand where they're coming from, but they're being ridiculously nitpicky.

I think this is ignoring the spirit of veganism. There's not really a single reason to be vegan that I've heard of that applies to breast milk. Ethics- your breastmilk is ethical. Health- breastmilk is far healthier than a "proper" vegan diet for a newborn. Animal protein intolerances- if the baby is thriving on breastmilk, clearly not a problem.

Quote:
Originally Posted by BlessedOne View Post
And in regards to "pushy cows"- That statement tells me that the mommy is not near the baby.... or she wouldn't be begging to be milked. Anyone that has nursed and been away from baby for a bit, is well aware of how it feels to be engorged and hurt. So if the cow is begging to be milked, maybe it shouldn't be separated from its child.
It's actually worse than that. We've selectively bred cows to produce an obscene amount of milk. Even if cows were kept with their calves, it's unlikely the calves would be able to nurse enough to make the cow comfortable. (all the more reason to keep calves with the cow) We've really screwed cows over.
07-01-2014 05:14 AM
JamieCatheryn Modern cows are bred to produce far more than the calf will drink, at top production you might see like 15x what a calf needs produced. They can adjust their production to demand, many family cows are milked once per day for 1-2 gallons if they are kept with calves, only making double the calf's need, but it takes adjustment and I'm not sure if a dairy breed cow can go much lower in production.

Human milk doesn't count as dairy for many reasons. It's about the easiest thing in the world for human babies to digest (whereas cow's milk is very hard), it counts as a clear liquid, medically. It's also given with the mother's complete consent and intention

Besides categories shouldn't be such a volatile and emotion filled debate if you are confident in your choices, let it roll off your back if somebody is stupid or rude.
06-30-2014 10:12 PM
BlessedOne To above poster-
"You are what you eat.
...so
Free range cows eat a vegan diet, ergo eating free range cows is vegan.

Free range cows eat a vegan diet, ergo free range cow milk is vegan."

Yes the COW is vegan....EATING the cow is not vegan. No one said that we are what we eat eats. If someone eats me, it doesn't mean that THEY are vegetarian. If that was true then most of us would be animal poop.....as that is what many plants "eat".

And in regards to "pushy cows"- That statement tells me that the mommy is not near the baby.... or she wouldn't be begging to be milked. Anyone that has nursed and been away from baby for a bit, is well aware of how it feels to be engorged and hurt. So if the cow is begging to be milked, maybe it shouldn't be separated from its child.
06-28-2014 12:49 PM
Adeptus42
Quote:
Originally Posted by PikkuMyy View Post
Yes, this is one of the dumbest arguments I've ever heard from meat-eaters, although I haven't heard it myself. As for the vegan who was saying it to you, as her/him "What would you like me to do? Feed my baby on cow's milk?"
Nope. Surely they are just looking to make you admit a vegan diet would kill the kid.

It's a childish reason to bug you, but it is what it is.
06-28-2014 12:44 PM
Adeptus42
Quote:
Originally Posted by kama'aina mama View Post
That's a pure distortion of a definition. It's like claiming that someone born without hands isn't a human because they don't have an opposable thumb.

Your milk is not a dairy product. You are not in any way exploited against your will to provide milk to your DD. It's a pointless and specious arguement. These people are trying to push your buttons. Don't let them.
Correct! Kinda.... Sorta... Not really

Human milk is not a dairy product according to websters.
"1 : a room, building, or establishment where milk is kept and butter or cheese is made 2 a : the department of farming or of a farm that is concerned with the production of milk, butter, and cheese b : a farm devoted to such production 3 : an establishment for the sale or distribution chiefly of milk and milk products"

Also my goat milk isn't a dairy product because it isn't on a farm.
My wife's cousin's cow's milk isn't a dairy product either because again it is just a pet.

So yes that point is true.

But that's not how we use the term "Dairy" in the modern anglosphere lexicons.

The real question isn't one hinged on the classification of the production facility, but rather one of the nature of the product itself.

Your response fails to address the matter at issue and merely obfuscates the point.


(Ps to the consent question see friendly cows and voluntary cannibalism.

P.p.s. I have known cows that literally get mad when you don't milk them and come find you to get milked. Cows are cute but can be very pushy)
06-28-2014 12:25 PM
Adeptus42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ruthla View Post
Quote:
Originally Posted by candiland
Actually, "vegans" do not eat OTHER species' meats and fluids. You can eat breastmilk, placenta, - heck, ass, for all I care! - and it's still vegan.

Are you saying that somebody could be a vegan cannibal?
Yep. That is exactly what they are implying.

The poorly thought out mental gymnastics in an attempt to deny reality boggles the mind.

Breast milk is NOT vegan.

But, so what?

Eat vegan if you want, it's your choice. Just don't expect a growing child to be able to live on that kind of diet. Kids need vast ammounts of easily digsted whole proteins and fats. For infants in particular they need more than their little Tummys can fit. That's why we feed them so often.

As an adult you can live fine on a vegan diet because you don't need the protein and energy density (infact most of us could use a little less energy density). But a newborn baby is literally processing food almost 24/7 and even then needs the good rich high fat and protein milk.
06-28-2014 12:11 PM
Adeptus42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Meiri View Post
We are what we eat, correct? Therefor, since you are Vegan, your milk is vegan milk. No animal products went into it, only whatever you are eating.
You are what you eat.
...so
Free range cows eat a vegan diet, ergo eating free range cows is vegan.

Free range cows eat a vegan diet, ergo free range cow milk is vegan.

So if human milk is okay because the human is vegan, then bovine milk is okay so long as the bovine is vegan.

If you say that the difference is in consent, then milk from a socialized cow that likes being milked (think "family pet". Or family friend if you want) as a socializing activity is vegan.

For your argument to be logically consistent the following MUST apply.

A1: A foods vegan status is determined by the food being herbivorous or eating vegan food. (In this case ALL animals are vegan as all biochemical energy is originally derived from vegetable matter, see predation pyramid)

And/OR

A2: a food's vegan status is determined by consent. So a human's or cow's meat or byproduct can be vegan if the animal consents. (For example consensual cannibalism would be vegan)

If you reject either of these points, then you must logically also reject your arguments in favor of human milk being vegan.


Rather than all the mental gymnastics, excuses, and exceptions why not admit that while a vegan diet can sustain human life, it is incapable of growing it from infancy?

Why run from the obvious conclusion?
12-20-2004 03:35 PM
Ruthla
Quote:
Originally Posted by candiland
Actually, "vegans" do not eat OTHER species' meats and fluids. You can eat breastmilk, placenta, - heck, ass, for all I care! - and it's still vegan.
Are you saying that somebody could be a vegan cannibal?
12-18-2004 10:26 PM
shaper nak

my dad is ALWAYS teasing w/the breastmilk vegan thing........ it gets so tired, really. but he has a real dorky sense of humour so i just tell him it wasnt funny the first time

melissa
12-18-2004 08:22 PM
Charles Baudelaire
Quote:
Originally Posted by candiland
Actually, "vegans" do not eat OTHER species' meats and fluids. You can eat breastmilk, placenta, - heck, ass, for all I care! - and it's still vegan.
MMMM. Ass!
12-18-2004 07:22 PM
candiland Actually, "vegans" do not eat OTHER species' meats and fluids. You can eat breastmilk, placenta, - heck, ass, for all I care! - and it's still vegan.
12-18-2004 06:59 PM
PikkuMyy Yes, this is one of the dumbest arguments I've ever heard from meat-eaters, although I haven't heard it myself. As for the vegan who was saying it to you, as her/him "What would you like me to do? Feed my baby on cow's milk?"
12-18-2004 12:16 AM
root*children
Quote:
Originally Posted by saritabeth
I would just moo at them
:LOL :LOL :LOL
12-17-2004 09:02 PM
AngelBee How dumb can people be?????????? Seriously, that is the most ignorant thing I have ever heard!
12-17-2004 09:02 PM
FoxintheSnow people say the dumbest things!
12-17-2004 09:01 PM
saritabeth Im sorry, that is just the stupidest thing I have ever heard.

I would just moo at them
12-17-2004 08:58 PM
Charles Baudelaire
Quote:
Originally Posted by rastamama
: I need help.

This is the second time I have been told my daughter isn't vegan because she breastfeeds both times i just thought the person was an idiot and didn't really argue, but i guess i need a good comeback, because it seems to be a problem for people to understand. any good comebacks or quick responses to keep on hand would be great. what would you mamma's say?

tia
How about, "Oh, guess you're right."

Whether you agree or don't, what are they going to come back with? Nothin' that I can think of.

Good for you, Tia. Basically, who cares what idiots say?
12-17-2004 08:55 PM
rastamama Thanks Mammas

for all the ideas, i have been challenged both by a vegan and a non vegan and i think both times they were trying to belittle me. trying to make me seem like a hypocryte or something, but i know i'm doing the best for my daughter so who cares about thier hangups right? just wanted a few ideas of snappy comebacks, i like " that is the most ridiculous thing i have ever heard"

and thanks for the links!
12-15-2004 12:22 PM
root*children
Quote:
Originally Posted by kama'aina mama
That's a pure distortion of a definition. It's like claiming that someone born without hands isn't a human because they don't have an opposable thumb.

Your milk is not a dairy product. You are not in any way exploited against your will to provide milk to your DD. It's a pointless and specious arguement. These people are trying to push your buttons. Don't let them.

sheesh. some people just wanna pick fights, huh? ideeeeeots.
12-15-2004 10:58 AM
QueenSheba'sMom ITA, human milk is for human babies.

otherwise, animal milk is *absolutely* not vegan and is very exploitative.

but human milk is a natural bodily fluid that belongs to the baby. it's the extension of the transition from pregnancy. the milk belongs to baby as much as it does to you. it is a very essential part of the baby's further development.

when they're in utero they live off of you, too. is that vegan? puhhhleeeaaase.

you share a body for a while. even after they're born.

lanolin, like lansinoh, on the other hand, is not vegan.
12-15-2004 10:49 AM
love2all OMG---

some people are idiots
12-15-2004 08:15 AM
captain optimism I read in the Vegetarian Resource Group's Simply Vegan that ALL vegan babies should be breastfed as long as possible.

I had no idea there were people foolish enough to assert that breastmilk was not a part of a vegan diet.
12-15-2004 06:13 AM
BinahYeteirah Tell the idiot that a vegan not breastfeeding because it "isn't vegan" is the equivalent of vegans trying to prevent animals from nursing their young or trying to stop predatory animals from hunting each other. It just doesn't make any sense. I can envision a future utopia in which all animals will be a peace with one another (the lion with the lamb, etc.), but I can't envision a utopia without breastfeeding.

I read in The Sunfood Diet that mother's breastmilk is the most karmically positive food available for humans. Even if one does agee with *all* the author's ideas (it is written from a vegan raw foodist's perspective), this point makes perfect sense to me. Breastmilk is not only given freely, it is given with love and contact that is nourishing in itself.

In any case, it is probably not worth your time to say any of this. Just say, "That is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard," as mamajamma recommended.
12-15-2004 05:48 AM
amyandelle
Quote:
Originally Posted by Meiri
We are what we eat, correct? Therefor, since you are Vegan, your milk is vegan milk. No animal products went into it, only whatever you are eating.

Look at them like they have just sprouted another head and in all seriousness ask how feeding her something known to be less healthy is good when part of the point of being vegan is to be healthy.

Another possibility along the lines of what Binah Yeteirah said: Are you as the mother mammal not allowed to voluntarily feed your own baby your own milk? Look really confused when you ask them that one.

Alternatively, tell them they are idiots. Speak truth to stupidity.
ITA!!!
This thread has more than 30 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off