Tom’s of Maine (www.tomsofmaine.com, 800-FOR-TOMS): The Honeysuckle Baby Shampoo is a gentle, synthetic-free baby shampoo
Take a look at some past Mothering.com Expert Q&A’s for suggestions for other organic and all-natural baby clothes, toys and furniture.
Do you have specific
recommendations for those suffering from fibrocystic breast condition
and “estrogen dominance”? I understand that
“parabens” are to be eliminated-methyl, etc. I was surprised
to see “paraben” in a shampoo from Whole Foods.
Regarding the first part of your question, The Green
Guide is a publication intended to make you a more conscious
consumer and inform you of the environmental and health concerns in the
world around you. We don’t offer medical advice, so please do
consult your doctor about recommendations for treatment regarding
fibrocystic breast condition.
However, your reference to parabens
raises an important issue about environmental influences on personal
health, some of which you can avoid.It’s great that you’re
reading labels. With the proliferation of industrial chemicals being
used in personal care products, you should never assume that products
are safe before carefully reading the ingredients listed on the label.
And you are correct in understanding that parabens should be avoided.
Methyl-, propyl-, ethyl- and butyl-parabens have been shown to mimic
estrogen in rodents and to stimulate the growth of human breast-cancer
cells in laboratory tests, and according to a study published in the
Jan/Feb 2004 Journal of Applied Toxicology, they have been
found in tissue samples from human breast tumors. Besides popping up in
shampoos and deodorants, parabens have been found in makeup, sunscreen,
lotions, and a host of other personal care products for both adults and
children, even when those products carry a “non-toxic”
label.
Despite having been found in breast tumors, parabens have
not been found to influence the development of fibrocystic breast
condition, but other environmental exposures have.
It’s
believed that fibrocystic breast condition is related to hormonal
imbalances between estrogen and progesterone—usually too much
estrogen and too little progesterone, and one way to avoid extra
estrogen hormones is by eating organic meat and dairy products. An
estimated 80% of U.S. cattle are treated with hormone implants, which
spur growth and increase feeding efficiency. Added hormones also add to
the salability of meat, making cattle bloated and more fatty and
therefore heavier, allowing farmers to charge more for the meat.The
hormones build up in fatty tissue, which then ends up on your plate and
in your body.
The National Institutes of Health listed caffeine
as another potential culprit in fibrocystic breast condition, and the
easiest way to avoid it is to cut caffeinated coffee, colas, chocolate,
tea, and pain relievers out of your diet.But that’s not to say you
can’t enjoy these altogether. Take a look at our Coffee and Tea
product reports at thegreenguide.com/reports for a complete list of
organically grown, chemical-free decaffeinated drinks that will ease the
transition.
While the above two factors have not been shown in
medical studies to cause fibrocystic breast disease, doctors and
patients have provided anecdotal evidence that eliminating them from a
daily diet has resulted in a reduction of cysts and breast pain and
tenderness.
And again, although parabens have not been found to
influence the development of this condition, it’s good as a
general rule to avoid any kind of hormone-disrupting chemicals no matter
what your current health condition is.In addition to parabens, here are
a few to look out for:
- Alkylphenol ethoxylates (APEs),
which are found in shampoos and conditioners
- Bisphenol-A (BPA),
which is found in polycarbonate water bottles (identifiable by their #7
recycling code), resins that line food cans and dental sealants
- Phthalates, which are widely used in cosmetics (and masked on
ingredient lists by the umbrella term “fragrance”), soft
vinyl toys, flooring and medical tubing
Reducing your
exposure to any synthetic chemical is a healthy lifestyle change,
especially when they could potentially aggravate certain health
problems.But as with any medical concern, it’s important to
consult your doctor and ask as many questions as possible.
Where can I find responsible
shoes?
The shoe industry, particularly the sports shoe
industry, has been under the spotlight for more than a decade for their
reliance on sweatshop labor in Asian factories where long workdays and
exposures to harmful adhesives such as benzene-based glues are
common. Thankfully, the scrutiny is beginning to pay off: Though
we’re still a long way from a mainstream “green” shoe,
large companies are growing more socially responsible. In 1997, pressure
from activists and media coverage brought about the organization of the
non-profit Fair Labor Association which independently monitors labor
conditions for Adidas, Nike, Puma, Reebok and others. Puma says it
is observing the manufacturing environment and workers' health and
Adidas has produced a Guide to Environmental Practice for its
suppliers. Reebok has also claimed that it is reducing packaging
waste, working on efficient transport and conducting an inventory to
reduce climate-change emissions. All of these companies are
eliminating polyvinyl chloride (PVC) from their lines, reducing the
production of carcinogenic dioxins as a byproduct of PVC’s
manufacture. One standout product is Nike’s new Considered line
uses PVC-free leather, cotton and hemp, is vegetable tanned, and
contains no chemical adhesives ($65–$110).
Hiking gear
has also advanced : Jade’s Vigilante Pachira hiking boots
($74.95) have soles made from recycled materials, including
post-consumer tires and uppers of 50 percent hemp, 50 percent cotton.
Naturally pest-resistant hemp is a popular choice in eco-friendly shoes,
but is not yet certified organic or grown in the U.S.
In the
summer, sandals that breathe are a must, but popular
“jellie” varieties are made of PVC and contain plasticizing
phthalates, known to disrupt hormones. For alternatives,
Birkenstock’s Gizeh thong ($90) and Sparta sandal ($110) include
comfy footbeds made of cork recycled from the bottling industry and
blended with natural latex. Worn soles can also be sent back for a
“tuneup.” Another option is Splaff’s
100 percent vegan sandals, handmade from recycled car
and bike tires ($38.95). Chacoallocates 3 percent of
after-tax profits to environmental non-profits and produces a
slip-resistant Flip ($50), supportive Zong sandals ($75), and
men’s leather sandals ($115–$140).
Unfortunately,
there aren’t many high fashion “green” shoes, though
Stella McCartney does produce vegan footwear available from Nordstroms.
Note, however, that while they may include no animal products, some
vegan shoes contain PVC and other materials that are hardly
green.
Resources
Sweatshops.org lists
companies producing from better factories.
Jade Planet
503-297-2093
Birkenstock
Splaff
414-527-9684 (866-88VEGAN)
Chaco 970-527-4990
Nike Considered
800-806-6453
Now that mad cow disease has
been found in America, I want to feed my family more fish and less beef,
but I'm also worried about unhealthy levels of mercury in tuna and
cancer-causing chemicals in farmed salmon! My daughter is in preschool,
and I'm pregnant again. Plus, we'd like to avoid eating overfished
species. Which fish can I in good health and conscience buy?
It's wonderful that you care about fish populations as well as
your family's health. The good news is that there are still lots of
fish, rich in protein and heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids, that are
low in toxins and not overfished. These include wild Alaskan salmon,
which can be bought fresh from April through September and frozen or
canned the rest of the year, and sardines (which are high in calcium).
Here's a breakdown of the toxins most commonly found in fish, and how to
avoid them.
Mercury
Because
you're pregnant and have a young child, you have good reason to be
cautious about dietary exposure to mercury, which is found at highest
levels in some species, such as tuna and swordfish. Fetuses, infants and
young children, whose brains and nervous systems are rapidly developing,
are at greatest risk of harm from neurotoxins such as mercury. "Mercury
ingested during pregnancy can damage an unborn baby's central nervous
system, leaving the baby with slower than normal brain development,"
Philip J. Landrigan, M.D. and Herbert L. Needleman, M.D. write in
Raising Healthy Children in a Toxic World (Rodale, 2001).
Because mercury is stored in our body fat, just as it is in fish, women
planning to have children should also avoid high-mercury fish well
before they become pregnant. According to the Centers for Disease
Control, 8 percent of American women have levels of mercury in their
blood that could prove harmful to fetuses. Adults can suffer harm, as
well: In April, 2003, Environmental Health Perspectives reported that 89
percent of fish-eating subjects had blood mercury levels above the
safety threshold of 5 micrograms per liter; several showed symptoms of
mercury poisoning such as fatigue, decreased memory and joint pain.
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) advise that, in general, young children,
pregnant women, nursing mothers and women of childbearing age should eat
no more than two or three meals, or 12 ounces, of fish and shellfish a
week. High-mercury fish-shark, swordfish, king mackerel, tilefish and
tuna- should be limited to no more than 4-6 ounces once a week for these
individuals. But some environmental health organizations, including the
Environmental Working Group (EWG), have been recommending that people in
these high-risk groups eat moderate-mercury fish no more than once a
month, and high-mercury fish not at all. In fact, earlier versions of a
December, 2003 FDA/ EPA draft advisory on fish suggested that high-risk
individuals completely avoid high-mercury fish; however, this
proscription did not appear in the draft that was released. Also in
December, after being pressed to do so for years by EWG and others, FDA
finally added tuna to the list of fish that should be eaten no more than
once a week.
Persistent Organic Pollutants
(POPs)
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), banned in the
U.S. since 1978, were found at far higher levels in farmed than wild
salmon, according to a study released in January 2004, include, members
of a class of chemicals known as persistent organic pollutants, or POPs.
Like mercury, POPs accumulate in animal fats and rise in the food chain,
so that large predator fish will generally contain higher amounts.
Because farmed salmon are raised on feed that includes ground-up animals
and fish, their bodies accumulate these pollutants. Other POPs found in
fish include the organochlorine pesticide dieldrin and dioxins-- the
result of chlorine paper bleaching and manufacturing and incineration of
PVC plastic, and the most toxic man-made chemicals known.
PCBs,
which are neurotoxins, hormone disruptors and probable carcinogens, were
found at levels seven times higher in farmed than in wild salmon. PCBs
are also found at high levels in fish from polluted water bodies,
varying from locale to locale; state health advisories list which fish
should not be consumed by children, pregnant or nursing women, and women
of childbearing age.
How to Avoid Fishborne
Toxins
Avoiding Mercury
As a general rule, The Green Guide and our medical advisory board,
including Drs. Landrigan and Needleman, agree with EWG's guidelines.
*Young children and pregnant or nursing women should not eat
high-mercury fish, and should limit meals of moderate-mercury fish to
once a month.
(This is a general rule, however, which means you
shouldn't worry unduly if you or your child occasionally get your fish
mixed up and eat the "wrong" kind. A once-in-a-while meal won't cause
harm-it's regular ingestion that allows mercury to build up in the
body.)
*Know your tuna: According to the FDA, tuna steak and
canned albacore (white) tuna generally contain up to three times more
mercury than canned light tuna. According to EWG guidelines, a pregnant
woman or young child can eat 4-6 ounces of moderate-mercury, canned
light tuna (one sandwich) per month.
*Fish lowest in mercury
include: Wild Alaskan salmon, sardines, squid, Arctic char, flounder,
sanddabs, scallops and sole. For moderate and high mercury fish lists,
and which fish are from healthy, recovering or overfished populations,
see www.thegreenguide.com
Avoiding
POPs
Check with the state department of health before
eating fish from local fresh or ocean waters, as worrisome levels of
PCBs as well as pesticides and other industrial chemicals may be
present.
In General
*Limit
fish consumption by category, not individual species. For example, both
cod and mahimahi are moderate-mercury fish, and only one from this
category should be eaten per month -not one meal of cod and one of
mahimahi.
*Don't eat the skin and fatty parts of fish, where
toxins collect.
*Eat cooked rather than raw fish, as cooking,
particularly grilling, burns off fat.
*For lists of specific
fish can be eaten regularly, once in a while, and not at all ("yes,"
"sometimes" and "no") fish, visit thegreenguide.com. A unique,
downloadable pocket fish guide, "Smart Shopper's Fish Picks," addresses
both overfishing and pollutants in fish that threaten human health. It
is regularly updated.
For more information, also see www.fda.gov, www.ewg.org, www.epa.gov/waterscience/
fish and www.map1.epa.gov to
learn which fish from which water bodies are currently safe or unsafe to
eat.
As a new
mother, I am concerned about toxic chemicals in my home, particularly in
household cleaning and body care products. I use an all-natural
detergent and diapers but was wondering what other sources of toxins I
should replace?
You are wise to be concerned about
the many unhealthy-and unnecessary- man-made chemicals in conventional
household and personal care products, including some shampoos, soaps and
lotions marketed for babies. "Babies and young children are
particularly vulnerable to environmental toxins, which can disrupt the
development of their rapidly growing nervous, hormonal and respiratory
systems," says Philip Landrigan, M.D., a Green Guide editorial advisor
and director of the Center for Children's Health and the Environment
(CCHE) at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York City. Happily
for our children's health, we can choose safer and more environmentally
sound alternatives in a growing green marketplace. But it's also
important not to worry too much: While there are many ways in which to
reduce your baby's exposure to toxins, you needn't feel you have to do
them all at once. It's hectic enough to be a new parent, and every
little change helps.
Following are some tips and safer
choices regarding some everyday household and baby items: laundry
detergents, pesticides, cleaning and body care products, and "teething"
toys. For more detailed, comprehensive information, including extensive
product lists, in these and other categories, such as baby bottles,
pressed woods and wood finishes, flooring, carpets, mattresses and other
decorating products, please see Product Reports and search the Archives
at www.thegreenguide.com.
Also see the Resources section below.
Remember,
especially as your baby begins to crawl about and explore, that even
least-toxic alternative products should be kept well out of the reach of
children and behind locks, as any cleaning or laundry formulation can be
toxic if swallowed or touched.
LAUNDRY
PRODUCTS
You've already taken two big steps by choosing an
all-natural laundry detergent and all-cotton diapers (organic,
hopefully), both of which make daily contact with your baby's sensitive
skin. To ensure that a laundry detergent is as natural as possible,
choose products that list all ingredients and are plant- rather than
petroleum-based. It is also a good idea to choose fragrance-free
detergents, as fragrance residues on clothes can produce skin irritation
and rashes as well as watery eyes and noses, according to Harvey Karp,
M.D., author of The Happiest Baby on the Block (Crown, 2002).
Allergies, Dr. Karp says, can develop through repeated early exposures
to irritating substances.
Also to be kept out of the
laundry room: Chlorine bleach, also called sodium hypochlorite, which
gives off caustic fumes and is highly poisonous if swallowed. Choose
non-chlorine bleaches that use sodium percarbonate or sodium perborate,
instead. Or, give diapers a pre-wash soak in water mixed with either
borax, lemon juice, hydrogen peroxide or white vinegar.
Some best, least-toxic laundry products to look for:
Seventh
Generation
Ecover
Sun & Earth
Bi-O-Kleen
FRAGRANCES
Fragrances in conventional
laundry detergents and other home cleaning products, room-freshener
sprays and cosmetics (including your expensive perfumes, if your baby is
sensitive to them) can cause responses that "range from runny nose to
wheezing and coughing" and aggravate asthma and allergies, Dr. Karp
warns.
While even natural scents, particularly
citrus-based ones, can cause irritation and provoke allergic reactions,
synthetic fragrances pose a more insidious health threat because they
contain chemicals known as phthalates, which have been found to produce
cancer of the liver and birth defects, including reproductive system
abnormalities, in lab animals. Phtalates are not required to be
disclosed on labels and so can hide behind the catchall term "Fragrance"
on ingredients lists.
When buying any kind of bodycare or
household product, your safest bet is to look for "Fragrance Free" or
products that specify that they use only 100% plant essential oils,
which do not use phthalates.
HOUSEHOLD
CLEANING PRODUCTS
A major source of indoor air pollutants
is conventional cleaning products, loaded with fragrances and
petroleum-based volatile organic compounds, or VOCs, that vaporize into
the air you and your infant breathe. VOCs can evaporate, or "offgass"
from cleaning products, paints and finishes long after they have dried.
The combined emissions of all these offgassing products in our
households produce a potent indoor smog! As infants breathe
proportionately more air, for their body size, than adults do, their
exposure is all the greater.
Safety alert: Note that
chlorine bleach (sodium hypochlorite) should never be mixed with any
product containing ammonia or quaternium compounds, as this produces
toxic chlorine gas. Best to remove these toxic substances from your home
altogether!
Scouring Powder
Bon Ami powder is a
chlorine-free substitute for Comet or Ajax
Some Safer
Cleaning Products:
The Green Guide editors' favorite nontoxic
floor cleaner is one cup white distilled vinegar per gallon of hot
water. For extra strength, use ½ cup borax (like vinegar, a natural
disinfectant) and 2 gallons of water, plus 1/4 cup of any liquid soap.
All-Purpose Cleaners:
AFM Super Clean concentrated
all-purpose cleaner/degreaser vAubrey Organics Earth Aware All-Purpose
Household Cleanser
Dr. Bronners' Sal Suds
Ecover Natural
All-Purpose Cleaner
Vermont Soapworks Liquid Sunshine Nontoxic
Cleaner
Dish soaps:
Ecover cleansers and dish soaps
Naturally Yours Gentle Soap
Seventh Generation Natural Dish
Liquid
Heavy-Duty Cleaners
Some of the most toxic and
corrosive ingredients are found in conventional drain, oven and
toilet-bowl cleaners. Here are some safer alternatives:
Earth Friendly Earth Enzymes Drain Opener
Naturally Yours Enz-Away
enzyme drain opener
AFM SafeChoice Safety Clearn for toilets
Ecover Toilet Cleaner
Ecover Cream Cleaner for ovens
1st
EnviroSafety's Multi-purpose Cleaner for ovens
A
make-your-own, VOC-free oven cleaner: Make a paste of ½ cup washing
soda (sold in supermarket laundry aisles), ½ cup baking soda and water.
Apply to oven overnight, and rinse off next day wearing rubber gloves.
For Windows, use ½ cup white vinegar in 2 cups water, or
buy Earth Friendly Products handy vinegar-based Window Kleener in a
spray bottle.
All-Natural Disinfectants:
Earth Power
Herbal Disinfectant
Seventh Generation Sanitizers
PESTICIDES
It's very important to
avoid the use of synthetic pesticides, including herbicides and
fungicides, in your home and garden, especially if you have a small baby
or toddler or are pregnant.
Many insecticides are
organophosphate neurotoxins that pose an especially grave threat to
developing brains and nervous systems. Because of the danger to young
children, Dursban/chlorpyrifos, a common household pesticide, has been
banned for residential uses since 2001. Diazinon, another
organophosphate, has been banned for use on produce that's most
frequently eaten by children. Other pesticides, such as atrazine, have
been shown to have hormone-disrupting properties in wildlife.
Use least toxic pest controls. Seal cracks and mend leaks that
attract pests. In summer, removing sources of standing water such as old
tires, rain gutters, wading pools and potted plant saucers eliminates
mosquito breeding spots. Boric acid, which kills cockroaches, can be
scattered at the backs of shelves and counters, so long as it's kept out
of the reach of children and pets.
For more ways to control
pests without synthetic chemicals, see "Common Sense Home Pest Control"
at www.
thegreenguide.com/doc.mhtml?i=16&sec=2 And the Washington Toxics
Coalition's www.watoxics.org
To safely dispose of pesticides, call your local solid-waste
agency or 800cleanup (cleanup.org) or the National Pesticide Information
Center, 800-858-7378
PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS
Many
conventional personal care products marketed for babies contain
questionable ingredients. For instance, Johnson's Baby Shampoo uses
quaternium -15, a preservative that contains formaldehyde, a probable
human carcinogen, according to the EPA. And "fragrance," as noted above,
is a catch-all term disguising the presence of problematic phthalates.
To complicate matters, the labels "organic, natural and hypoallergenic"
are currently unregulated with regard to personal care products and thus
meaningless, with exception of certified organic essential plant oils.
Because synthetic fragrances offgass from adult products
into the air your baby breathes, and we hold our babies against our
skins, where products can rub off on them, we should take the precaution
of using less toxic cosmetics for their sake as well as our own.
Also sidestep antibacterials, which work no better at
germ-killing than regular soap, according to the National Institutes of
Health, and contribute to the rise of antibiotic-resistant super germs
that threaten our health.
Therefore, it pays to read
labels. For an article explaining what ingredients to avoid and why,
plus a downloadable wallet-size list of the "Dirty Dozen" ugliest
ingredients in personal care products, go to
www.thegreenguide.com/doc.mhtml?i=100+S=uglies
Below are
some short lists of products for babies and adults that are free of the
most problematic synthetic chemicals:
Soaps & Shampoos
In general, look for unscented pure vegetable oil soaps, such as ones
based on olive or coconut oil Aubrey Organics facial bar soaps contain
no synthetic chemicals.
Kiss My Face Bare Naked Bar Soap is free
of fragrances and dyes
Vermont Soapworks has "supermild" soaps
scented with essential oils
Aubrey Organics Soothing Blue Chamomile Shampoo
Aveda Scalp
Benefits Balancing Shampoo contains botanical ingredients
Dr.
Hausschka Herbal Hair Conditioner
John Masters Shampoo and
Conditioner
J.R. Liggett's Old-Fashioned Bar Shampoo-plus, no
bottle!
Terressentials Pure Earth Hair Wash is detergent- and
petroleum-free with organic botanical oils
Tom's of Maine Natural
Baby Shampoo & Body Wash is based on gentle plant oils with no synthetic
chemicals
Moisturizers and Diaper Creams
Moisturizers:
Aubrey Organics Honeysuckle Rose Complexion and Body
Moisturizer
Burt's Bees Vitamin E Body & Bath Oil
Jason
Natural Cosmetics Vitamin K Creme Plus for Skin
Kiss My Face Ultra
Hydrating Moisturizer
Diaper Creams:
Plain zinc oxide
lotion, inexpensive and available at pharmacies, is a least-toxic
choice.
Burts Bees Diaper Ointment combines zinc oxide with
pleasant plant oils
A note on baby powder: Talc, a mineral
found in many face and body powders, has a structure similar to
asbestos, which has been linked to lung and ovarian cancers. For adults,
a healthier alternative is cornstarch. But because any fine particles,
including cornstarch, can penetrate deep into lungs and cause breathing
problems, it's best not to powder baby.
Sunscreens and
Sunblocks
These products should not be used on babies under
the age of six months, who should be kept out of the sun between the
most burning hours of 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. When they do go out, keep them
in the shade and protect them with cute floppy hats and tightly-woven
clothing.
For older babies, zinc oxide formulations are the
least toxic currently known.
Zinc Oxide Ointment, a popular
diaper lotion, will also block sun.
Mustela Bebe/Enfant
uses zinc oxide and titanium dioxide, which physically block sun without
added chemicals.
Epicuren Discovery Zinc Oxide Sunscreen
and U.V. Natural use only zinc oxide.
PAINTS
Lead, a brain-damaging heavy metal
banned from use in household paint in 1978, remains an all-too-live
health threat to young children's development, persisting in an
estimated 38 million U.S. homes. If your home was built in 1978, and old
paint is flaking or crumbling, have the chips tested for lead by an
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) certified lab. Otherwise, your
infant or toddler may suffer lead poisoning from inhaling or ingesting
lead dust. Even absent a full-blown case of lead poisoning, according to
pediatric psychiatrist Herbert L. Needleman, M.D. of the University of
Pittsburgh Medical Center, even low exposures to lead can contribute to
learning disabilities and antisocial behavior.
Certainly,
before undertaking any renovations in your home that may disturb old
paint, you should have it tested for lead. Because of its high
neurotoxicity and the danger of spreading the dust over a wide area,
never remove lead paint yourself; it must be removed and cleaned up by
a certified lead specialist when your family is not in residence.
When it comes to new paint, look on labels for no-VOC or
low-VOC formulations. By choosing these cleaner, greener paints you will
avoid such toxic VOCs as formaldehyde, benzene, toluene and xylene, all
known carcinogens or neurotoxins. Below are some better brands:
AFM Safecoat Zero VOC
BioShield Clay Paint (no-VOC, all
natural)
EcoSpec by Benjamin Moore (low-VOC)
Kelly Moore
Enviro-Coat Enamel (no-VOC)
For more information see
Resources, below.
TEETHING TOYS
Soon your baby will be
teething, if not already, and in search of soft things to chomp on.
While cheerful, colorful plastic teething toys are a popular gift item
for this age group, they can contain phthalates, those culprits found in
synthetic-fragranced cleaning and personal care products. Phthalates are
also used as plasticizers to soften PVC plastic, also known as vinyl. In
some lab tests that replicate the action of a chewing infant, phthalates
have been found to migrate from soft vinyl. As a precaution, the U.S.
Consumer Products Safety Commission has recommended that American toy
manufacturers not use soft vinyl in toys for children under the age of
three. Britain has banned all PVC toys, and a European Union report
recommends that all EU countries do the same.
Toy
companies that have gone PVC-free include Brio, Chicco, Early Start,
Lego, Little Tykes, Primetime Playthings, Sassy and Tiny Love. Lamaze
Infant Development is PVC-free for children under free.
RESOURCES
For more information on the
above products and ingredients, as well as on bedding, including crib
mattresses, furniture, paints, finishes, flooring, carpets and other
items for baby, please visit www.thegreenguide.com
Updates on dangerous chemicals in cleaning and other household
products and pesticides can be found at www.watoxics.org
The
ultimate pesticides clearinghouse is Pesticide Action Network. See www.panna.org
For chemicals
in personal care products, see www.nottoopretty.org
For info on antibiotic resistance, see www.apua.org
To find
EPA-certified labs and experts, contact the National Lead Information
Center, 800-424-LEAD; or see epa.gov/opptintr/lead
For details on chemicals in paints and extensive lists of brands and
where to find them, see "Paint Product Report" at www.thegreenguide.com
To distinguish reliable from unregulated labels and claims, go to www.ecolabels.org
For
studies on children's environmental health, go to Mount Sinai School of
Medicine's Center for Children's Health and the Environment at www.childenvironment.org
I am
concerned about toxic chemicals leaching from plastic into breastmilk
when it is stored and reheated. How to avoid this?
There
are two potentially hormone-disrupting chemicals that may leach from
plastic bottles or bags used to store or heat breast milk. The first is
bisphenol-A, which can enter milk from heated or scratched polycarbonate
(#7) bottles. The second is a class of chemicals known as phthalates,
plasticizers that can readily migrate from polyvinyl chloride (PVC #3).
As a general rule, milk should not be reheated in any plastic, as heat
promotes more leaching and even plastics with no known toxic properties
can melt at high temperatures.
Storing milk in soft plastic bags
is risky because they are easily punctured and difficult to seal.
Because you need an air-tight seal when storing breast milk, your best
choices are glass breastmilk storage or nursing bottles or small mason
jam jars. Gerber’s polypropylene nursers are made from a plastic
that has not been shown to release toxic chemicals. Most opaque and
colored bottles are not polycarbonate. Periodically check, though, to
make sure that bottles–whether plastic or glass–do not have
scratches and other signs of wear. This encourages leaching of chemicals
from plastic, and in the case of glass, make breakage more likely.
For brief storage and transport, soft plastic bags are convenient and
safe–just check that they aren’t made out of polyvinyl
chloride (PVC).
Also, don’t store your milk for too long.
According to a recent study published in The Archives of Childhood
Disease, breast milk that has been refrigerated for two days or more or
frozen has a lower antioxidant activity than fresh milk. Write the date
and time on labels and affix to the containers.
Finally, be aware
that a microwave can heat unevenly, creating pockets of scalding milk in
baby’s drink.
Products
Lansinoh Glass Breastmilk
Storage Bottles at www.lansinoh.com.
Gerber Seal ‘N Go
breast milk storage bags at www.gerber.com.
For more information, please
see The Green Guide’s Baby Bottle report at www.thegreenguide.com/reports.
I am looking for
environmentally friendly products to register for my upcoming baby
shower. Everything from clothes to nursery decor to furniture. Where
(and how) do I begin the search?
I love to get questions like
this. Like you, more and more new parents are helping to protect the
Earth–and their babies’ health–by purchasing green
products. Every step, no matter how small, has a positive impact when
you’re making environmentally friendly choices, and as your
friends and family will discover, shopping for the earth can be
rewarding and fun, even–or, rather, especially–in the
tiniest of sizes.
Here are some ideas to get you started, in the
categories you mentioned.
CLOTHING AND BEDDING
What to Look For: Certified Organic, Untreated Cotton or Wool
Breathable, absorbent cotton feels best next to a baby’s sensitive
skin. But conventional cotton farming is responsible for the use of
nearly $2.6 billion worth of pesticides annually–more than any
other crop, according to Pesticide Action Network North America. These
include organophosphate and carbamate pesticides, potent nervous-system
toxins that can sicken agricultural workers and contaminate the soil and
groundwater in farming communities. The synthetic nitrogen fertilizers
used on cotton can cause an illness known as “blue baby”
syndrome in infants whose formula is made with polluted water. The most
environmentally-friendly choice one can make is therefore Certified
Organic Cotton, grown without these toxic additives.
For
breathable insulation that naturally resists both water and fire, wool
has long been the tradtional choice for baby hats, sweaters, soakers,
booties, blankets and under-sheet absorptive padding. Certified organic
wool, sheared from sheep raised on organic feed, is increasingly
available in clothing and bedding for infants.
During processing,
chlorine bleaching and dyeing of these natural fabrics with toxic heavy
metals and petrochemical solvents, pollution of water is also a problem.
And, fabric treatments such as permanent press or water- and
stain-repellant may "offgass" such toxic chemicals as
formaldehyde, a respiratory irritant and probable carcinogen; and
perfluorochemicals, which have been associated with testicular and
bladder cancers in some human studies–and have shown up in the
blood of children tested at more than twice adult levels, according to a
2001 industry study.
Look for undyed, non-chlorine-bleached
cotton and Pure Grow wool, which is processed in more environmentally
sound ways. Sheep and their wool naturally come in a variety of lovely
shades, from white to beige to grey to dark brown. Look also for
"color-grown" cotton, which naturally appears in soft russet,
brown or sage. Other environmentally gentler alternatives include
fabrics that have been colored with natural dyes in a process sometimes
labeled as "phosphate-free" or "fiber-reactive,"
which results in less dye going down the drain.
Here are some top
product choices for organic, untreated infantwear, diapers and diaper
covers, and or/ baby sheets, towels and blankets.
Ecobaby, ecobaby.com,
888-320-2129 for organic baby clothes, bedding and towels and
furniture
Maggie’s Functional Organics, organicclothes.com, 800-609-8593
Patagonia, patagonia.com,
800-638-6464
Garden Kids, which has an irresistible organic cotton
receiving “blankie” and cap, gardenkids.com,
541-465-4544
Babyworks, babyworks.com, 800-422-2910
Eco-wise, ecowise.com,
512-326-4474
Natural Baby Company, http://store.yahoo.com/naturalbaby/info.html
The Natural Baby Catalog, kidsstuff.com, 888-550-2461
Lifekind makes
organic cotton sheets whitened with hydrogen peroxide, and organic
cotton and wool mattress pads, lifekind.com,800-284-4983
Diaper Service? To
wash those organic cotton diapers, consider registering for a diaper
service. To find one in your area, try the yellow pages or diapernet.com.
Green Disposable Diapers
Most eco-conscious
parents agree it’s a blessing to have both green cloth and
disposables on hand. More environmentally friendly disposables are
available from
Seventhgeneration.com
Tushies.com
Natureboyandgirl.com
Polyester
Fleece from Recycled Soda Bottles
Patagonia makes colorful, warm
hooded baby jackets and overalls from old PET bottles, patagonia.com
NURSERY DECOR
Paints
What to Look For: Low- or No-VOC
paints
You wouldn’t want your baby–or yourself,
especially when pregnant–breathing in toxic petrochemical VOCs, or
volatile organic compounds, which evaporate from conventional paints.
Instead, look on labels for no- or low-VOC paints, which, like
conventionals, can be mixed into any nursery-appropriate shade you
desire. Note: The Green Guide’s medical advisors warn that
pregnant women should never do the painting, even with the safest, most
fume-free paint, and should not linger in freshly painted rooms until
they’ve been well-ventilated and paint has fully dried (two weeks
to be safest). Here are some recommendations:
AFM Safecoat
Eggshell Zero VOC, afmsafecoat.com, 800-239-0321
Ecospec by
Benjamin Moore, benjaminmoore.com, 800-344-0400
Old Fashioned
Milk Paint (all natural), milkpaint.com, 978-448-6336
BioShield (natural
ingredients), bioshieldpaint.com, 800-621-2591
Carpeting
What to Look For: Natural Fibre
Area Rugs and Low- or No-Voc pads and underlays
For the nursery or
anywhere in the home, pediatricians Philip Landrigan, MD and Harvey
Karp, MD recommend the use of washable area rugs rather than
wall-to-wall carpeting. Smaller rugs can be taken up and thoroughly
washed or vacuumed on both sides to remove allergenic dust mites and
chemicals that accumulate from household products. Natural fibers are
preferable to synthetics, which pose a disposal problem as they
accumulate in landfills. VOCs are also often found in mothproofing,
water-stain treatments, synthetic backings, underlays and pads, and
adhesives or glues. Opt for unbacked dhurries or kilims, or carpets sewn
to natural backings with low-VOC glues. Some good places to start:
Natural Home,naturalhomeproducts.com, 707-824-0914
EarthWeave Carpet Mills,earthweave.com,706-278-8200
Eco Friendly
Flooring, 866-250-3273, for hemp, seagrass and sisal carpets, some
backed with natural rubber
Casa Natura, 702-543-7003, for
untreated wool carpetsw and pads
Eco Choices, fax 702-543-7003,
for untreated wool, natural adhesives, hemp or cotton backings.
Yayla Tribal rugs, wool naturally dyed made by refugees working with
non-profit organizations, 617-576-3249
Soft
Floorcovering Alternatives: Natural Linoleum or Cork
Vinyl flooring and others surfaces should be avoided, as it has been
found to offgass phthalates, which are plasticizing chemicals linked to
respiratory problems in children as well as potential hormone disruption
and liver cancers. Also, the production and incineration of vinyl
release toxic dioxins into our water and air, and thence into the food
chain.
The answer? Baby’s rollovers and tumbles can better
be padded by natural linoleum or cork.
Natural linoleum is made
of sawdust, linseed oils, natural pigments and a jute backing. According
to Christina Erickson of Green By Design in Santa Monica, California, a
linoleum floor for a child’s room “can be made colorful and
fun with a contrasting border, a collage or any sort of
pattern.”
Cork comes from the outer barks of living oaks in
Portugal, Spain, Algeria and Morocco; the flooring is often made from
scraps remaining after bottle corks have been punched out.
Where
to get them:
Cork and linoleum: Environmental Home Center, environmentalhomecenter.com, 800-281-9785
Linoleum: Planetary Solutions, planetearth.com,303-442-6228
Eco House, ecohaus.com,
503-222-3881
FURNITURE
As with flooring
(see above), vinyl should be avoided. So should furniture made with
conventional composite woods, plywood and particleboard, which can
offgass VOCs such as formaldehyde. It pays to choose furniture
that’s been finished with no- or low-VOC paints, stains or
finishes, as well.
Cribs
Pacific Rim Woodworking makes a crib from solid maple, either left
unfinished or finished with pure, raw tung and linseed oils. It can also
convert to a toddler bed, and at $639.95, its price is competitive with
its conventional counterparts. At abundantearth.com, 888-513-2784.
Pacific Rim
also makes solid wood, child-size tables and chairs. For other furniture
and retailers, see pacificrimwoodworking.com.
Other green cribs
and nursery furniture can be found at Ecobaby.com, 888-320-2129 and gaiam.com
The
best green wood comes bearing the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC)
label, which means that its been harvested from sustainably managed
forests. To put on your wish list: A curvy rocker, perfect for nursing
or rocking a baby to sleep, made by woodworker Gary Weeks of FSC
certified cherry, maple or mahogany. $1,600 and up at garyweeks.com,888-334-0307.
Crib Mattresses
For mattresses made with
all-natural latex, cotton and wool (naturally fire retardant, so toxic
flame retardant chemicals aren’t required), go to:
Lifekind.com,
800-284-4983
Gaiam.com (for Natura mattresses and cribs)
IKEA makes conventional mattresses, but they’re free of the most
problematic fire retardants, known as polybrominated diphenyl ethers
(pbdes.).
Crib futons, about half the price as all-natural
mattresses and made with all-organic cotton or cotton wrapped with wool,
are at
Abundant Earth, abundantearth.com,888–513-2784 or
Tonkatinkers, tonkatinkers.com, 309-837-3150
For more
extensive lists of products and companies, see Wood Furniture, Carpet,
Clothing, Mattress and Bedding Product Reports at thegreenguide.com
For more information:
Pesticide Action Network, panna.org
The Sustainable Cotton Projectg, sustainablecotton.org
Organic Trade
Association, ota.com/organic/woolfactsheet.html
I have concerns with
the vapor emitted from plastic toys. When I removed a new toy from the
trunk of the car on a warm day the smell/fume was very intense. Should I
be concerned about toxification from plastic toys?
You are
right to be concerned, as chemicals more readily escape from plastics
when heated. A very common plastic used in toys, including teethers and
other "mouth toys," is PVC (#3). Bad stuff, its production is
a source of carcinogenic dioxin in the environment. Soft PVC toys are
made flexible with phthalates, chemicals that have caused reproductive
system harm and liver cancer in animal tests. Tests in the European
Community have shown that phthalates can leach from soft PVC, posing a
threat particularly to small children prone to sucking or chewing on
toys.
In 1997, Greenpeace found hazardous levels of lead and
cadmium in some PVC toys and children’s vinyl raincoats.
Responding to these problems, some conscientious manufacturers, such
as Lego, Gerber, Playskool and Brio, are no longer making toys from PVC.
So next time you’re shopping, avoid vinyl or PVC toys, as well as
clothing, backpacks, bags, lunch pails and school items made of this
plastic, and instead seek out toys made from solid (preferably
sustainably sourced) wood, organic cotton, or safe plastics.
Holgate Toys and Tumbleweed Woodworks both provide sustainably
sourced wooden toys (holgatetoy.com, 800-499-1929; tumbleweedwoodworks.com, 800-497-3116). For organic
cotton stuffed toys, see Mama’s Earth (mamasearth.com,
800-620-7399).
Since Lego promotes their kits these days, to get
buckets of Lego bricks it’s best to contact the company and ask
for Item 4105 (miscellaneous bucket) or Item 4028 (world of bricks) (lego.com, 800-835-4386).
And please note: Health concerns about toys are not limited to
plastic—last summer, cereals containing Spider-Man toys were
pulled from shelves in many states because they included a battery
containing the brain-damaging heavy metal mercury.
For more
choices, see the December 2004 Guest Editor "
Environment and Families" column at Mothering.com, and
"Non-Toxic Toys" in issue 105 of The Green Guide at www.thegreenguide.com
What kinds of chemicals are used to make baby clothes
flame retardant? Are all sleep clothes treated with these chemicals and
how safe are they?
Most sleepwear made from synthetic
fiber is polyester and according to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety
Commission (CPSC), "less than 1% of either polyester or cotton sleepwear
garments are treated with flame retardant chemicals." The key word here
is "treated," which, in this case, does not mean exactly what one might
suppose. Treated or not, most children’s sleep clothes made of
synthetic fabrics will contain flame retardant chemicals in one way or
another. In some cases, the material is treated after it is woven or
after the garment is finished; in other cases, the flame retardant is
actually bonded into the composition of the fabric. Therefore, the most
chemical-free (as well as comfortable) option is untreated, snug-fitting
cotton stretchies. But it’s crucial to note that they must be
snug-fitting in order to comply with government safety rules.
Chemicals used on pyjamas or pyjama fabrics include halogenated
hydrocarbons (chlorine and bromine), inorganic flame retardants
(antimony oxides) and phosphate based compounds, all of which are the
basic building blocks of most conventional fire retardants. Like all
fabric finishes, fire retardants can offgass into the air children
breathe and irritate their skin. For purposes of the CPSC, synthetic
materials are either considered to be "inherently" flame resistant or
treated with flame retardants. Materials not requiring treatment include
most polyesters, modacrylic (Verel, SEF, Kanecaron); matrix (Cordelan);
and vinyon (Leavil). However, "inherently" flame resistant polyester
textiles are manufactured with built-in fire retardants This is because
the fire retardants can be chemically inserted into the polyester
compound, becoming a part of its molecular composition. The enhanced
polymers are quite stable, so polyester sleepwear is unlikely to pose a
health risk to your child, beyond the reduced breathability of the
fabric, which can contribute to overheating and rashes. And one can also
consider the negative impact on the environment during its manufacture
from petrochemicals.
Materials requiring chemical treatment include nylon, acetate, and
triacetate. The CPSC first adopted standards for children’s sleepwear
in 1971. The standards stipulated that all sleepwear exposed to a small
open flame must self-extinguish. Polyester garments and cotton garments
treated with chemical fire retardants were approved, but untreated
cotton garments were not. Subsequent data indicated a significant
decrease in sleepwear- and-fire related deaths and injuries among
children.
During the 1980s and 90s, pressure from consumers groups for organic
fibers lead to the CPSC’s relaxing the standards of the Flammable
Fabrics Act to include cotton garments. However, an important
distinction was made with regard to fit. According to the CPSC,
loose-fitting sleepwear made of cotton or cotton blends are associated
with 200 burn injuries every year. When the standards changed in 1997,
"snug-fitting" untreated cotton sleepwear became a legal alternative for
children over 9 months old. The same amendment eliminated all
restrictions for infant (0-9 months) sleepwear, since infants are less
mobile, and most burn injuries result from children playing with
fire.
Following the new CPSC standards all snug-fitting cotton sleepwear is
labeled with a hangtag that says "For child’s safety, garment should
fit snugly. This garment is not flame resistant. Loose-fitting garment
is more likely to catch fire." The permanent label says, "Wear
snug-fitting. Not flame resistant."
Flame resistant garments are usually labeled "Flame Resistant." These
are expected to have passed the rigorous testing parameters set by the
CPSC, which require that the fabric, seams and trim self-extinguish
after being exposed to an open flame. The fabric is tested as produced
and again after fifty cycles in a washing machine. Failure at any point
in the testing is supposed to stop the item from moving forward to
production. Garments cannot be retested and must comply with all CPSC
standards before going to stores. Most polyesters pass the testing,
whereas untreated cotton does not. The current regulations determine the
safety of cotton garments according to a set of measurements for each
size group. These measurements are based on testing done to determine
the optimum snugness necessary to prevent the garment from being
inflammable when exposed to an open flame. The standards are based on
studies that showed eliminating the airspace—and therefore the
oxygen—between the garment and the child’s skin significantly
diminished a cotton garment’s inflammability. (CPSC used dressed
mannequins for their testing.)
Cotton can be treated with fire retardants, though the strict CPSC
standards requiring all cotton garments to be snug-fitting and the
negative perception of treated natural fibers do not create a favorable
market for such innovation.
Your choices, then, from worst to best are 1) nylon or acetate
treated with fire retardants, 2) "inherently" flame resistant polyester
with fire retardants built into the polymer or 3) snug-fitting cotton
garments. The healthiest safe choice with the lowest embodied energy and
lowest ecological impact would be snug-fitting, organic cotton, long
johns or union suit-style pajamas with the "Wear snug-fitting. Not flame
resistant" label. These common sense choices conform to the CPSCs
standards, give the environment a break and provide your child with safe
and comfortable sleepwear. For where to get organic cotton children’s
sleepwear and other clothing, go to
www.thegreenguide.com and click on "Product Reports" and then
"Clothing."
We live in St.
Louis and I recently took my 2.5 yo son in for a blood/lead level test
and the tests came back at 15. He is now at my mother's, we have an
appointment set with a specialist to test our entire house for lead, and
we are in the midst of cleaning and purging. I am using melaleuca
products and a hepa filter on the vacuum cleaner in the house. What can
I do for my son to lower the lead? What should we expect as far as
damages to him and can they be reversed? What else could we be doing to
lower the chances of further lead poisoning? I am all for holistic
healing and have had amazing results for all of us, my husband and my
father are more skeptical.
Expert Mindy Pennybacker, editor of the Green Guide, elected to pass
this question on to her Senior Research Editor, Paul McRandle for prompt
attention.
We are sorry to hear about your son's blood lead levels and encourage
you to seek professional lead testing and containment for your home.
Done properly, lead abatement will greatly reduce the chance of any
further poisoning. The Centers for Disease Control note that major
sources of lead exposure for children are deteriorated lead-based paint
and the resulting dust and soil contamination. According to The
Environmental Protection Agency, home test kits are not accurate, so
please see the National Lead Information Center (NLIC) for a list of
specialists visit www.epa.gov/lead/nlic.htm or call 1-800-424-LEAD.
Also, please see the EPA's Lead page at www.epa.gov/lead
where you may download "Lead in Your Home: A Parent's Guide." I am
attaching a shorter EPA brochure, "Testing Your Home Fore Lead in Dust,
Paint and Soil" which you may download by clicking here.
For a thorough test of your house, you will want a lead risk
assessment conducted by a certified risk assessor. This will include
testing deteriorated paint, household dust from your child's room, play
areas, and elsewhere, and soil in play areas and elsewhere. You may also
have your water tested during the assessment, since water from leaded
pipes is another source of exposure. For certified risk assessors in
your state, please contact the NLIC (phone/website above). The assessor
will provide you with a report which should include options for
controlling every lead hazard found, ranging from short term, interim
fixes to permanent abatement of the lead problem. When it comes to
fixing problem areas, the EPA recommends that you hire a different
company to prevent a conflict of interest that might arise if the
assessor also performs the abatement.
Lastly, please speak to your pediatrician about a follow-up exam for
your son and whether any treatment might be appropriate.
Sincerely,
Paul McRandle
Senior Research Editor
The Green Guide
I am planning
on breastfeeding but wanted to know which baby bottles are best for when
I will need to pump. Any insight would be appreciated.
Recent, studies have raised concerns about certain types of baby
bottles. Fortunately there are plenty of safe options readily available
to new mothers. The following tips will make it easy to know which
products to look for and which to avoid.
Products to
avoid
Polycarbonate bottles: Bisphenol-A is a component of
#7 polycarbonate plastic, the clear, rigid variety of plastic from which
many baby bottles are made. This substance has been shown to be
"estrogenic": it is an endocrine-disruptor in lab animals,
altering reproductive organs and functions. Bisphenol-A can leach from
polycarbonate, especially when exposed to high temperatures and repeated
washings.
Rubber Nipples: Many bottle nipples are made of rubber,
which may contain low levels of contaminants known as nitrosamines.
These substances, found also in some foods and in tobacco, cause cancer
in lab animals and contribute to tobacco-related cancers in people.
Nitrosamines can be ingested through bottle nipples; however it is
unknown whether this kind of exposure increases the risk of cancer.
Because of cancer concerns, The Food and Drug Administration regulates
the amount of nitrosamines allowable in rubber nipples, but low levels
are still permissible.
Products to look for
Glass bottles: Because the risks to humans of bisphenol-A are unknown,
it makes sense to limit your baby's exposure to it. Glass baby bottles
are a time-tested alternative to polycarbonate plastic. Glass is a
renewable resource, easily recyclable, and does not leach toxic
chemicals. Glass bottles are, of course, subject to breakage, and there
are risks of serious cuts to your child. Additionally, glass can chip or
crack, and can break when sterilized, allowing glass splinters to end up
in baby's beverage. The American Academy of Pediatrics urges parents not
to let babies go to sleep with a bottle, and toddlers should not be
allowed to walk around with a bottle. These precautions help prevent
tooth decay and mouth injuries; they also help prevent breakage and
injuries from glass bottles. As with plastic, careful and regular
inspections of the bottle allow parents to detect any flaws in the
glass. Recycle any scratched, cracked, or chipped glass bottle.
Safe plastics: Although polycarbonate bottles containing bisphenol-A
are the most common kind of baby bottle on the market, there are other
plastic baby bottles available that do not contain bisphenol-A. These
opaque bottles are made of polypropylene and polyethylene, which are not
known to leach carcinogens or endocrine disruptors. Recycling symbols
can provide some information about the plastic: polyethylene has #1, #2,
or #4 on the underside, and polypropylene has #5. The surest way to know
whether a bottle is made of polycarbonate is to call the manufacturer.
Keep in mind, though, that all plastic bottles are petroleum products,
requiring the use of non-renewable resources.
Silicone nipples:
Replace standard rubber nipples (amber-colored) with clear, silicone
nipples. Not only are silicone nipples free of cancer-causing
nitrosamines, but they last longer. Inspect nipples regularly and
discard any with cracks or tears, which can harbor bacteria and also
pose a choking hazard.
Shopping Suggestions
Baby Bottles (#5 Plastic)
Rubbermaid Chuggables Bottles
Rubbermaid Sippin' Sport Bottles
Evenflo Colored Baby Bottles
Evenflo Baby Bottles (opaque, pastel)
Gerber Baby Bottles
(colors)
Medela Baby Bottles
Baby Bottles (Glass)
Lansinoh Glass Baby Bottles
Lamby Glass Baby Bottles
Evenflo
Glass Baby Bottles