I got the cheaper of the two on Joann.com, on the recommendation of several knitting friends who have the same one, and it's fine. My LYS actually also has that same red and cream ball winder, too. My one complaint about it is that the clamp tends to wiggle loose if you're winding ball after ball in a row, and needs to be tightened up a smidge every now and again. However, I did wind 1500 yards of laceweight on it this weekend without issue, so I think at least part of the problem was me learning just how tight to make the clamp on my table.