well hopefully my new midwife will be better then my first. although she was proved wrong by me alone, all her other guesses were close or right on. she guessed my first at 7 1/2- 8lbs, he was 9lbs 2 oz. my second my dr said that i'd be lucky if she was 7 1/2 lbs (guessed by an awful dr i hated) she was born at 9lbs 1 oz. My next dr said the baby would be over 10lbs and i needed to be induced... well she was born 9lbs 1 oz. i will be seeing a new midwife this time around and i will just expect another 9lbs baby.
Pretty accurate. I was able to gauge how big my last two were in comparrison to my first one. First was 8 lb 15 oz, second I knew felt a lot bigger. He was 9 lb 14 oz. Third felt much smaller. She was only 7 lb 4 oz. Midwife estimated almost 7 lbs ....2 weeks before her birth.
You could really tell by my belly too. I'm only 4'11 and 105 lbs when not pg.
Some midwives are very skilled at palpation and estimating fetal size. Some are not.
I know that i read about about a study they did...and ut was something like they had skilled midwives use palpation to estimate size, mothers use their intuition/guess , and doctors use ultrasound....
The midwives won hands down, followed by the mothers and last...yep, you guessed it....*smile*
i think that some midwives are very accurate-- we recently had a similar discussion on a midwifery list but to tell you the truth there are studies that show moms can be accurate if not the most accurate in predicting size...
Yes to what mwherbs said.
I'm just going over this for class tomorrow! A midwife's handbook says that "clinicians estimates and maternal guesses are equal to ultrasound in accuracy" in respect to fetal size.
so I just have to comment on inaccuracy though- with my first, before the use of routine ultrasounds, my doc said the day before my daughter was born- that she was 5 lbs and that I would be maybe a month before I had her- she was 10lbs 5 oz - and like I said born the next day-- boy was he wrong and in a time period when docs were supposedly relying on their "hand skills" more.
and you know what I did not guess weight but I thought she was big, because I was as big around as a tape measure and I was not a heavy person at that time- I can only guess that he thought I was a heavy person all the time or something.
1 - 20 of 25 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.