Hi, I was wondering if y'all could do me a favor. My MIL was told to circumcise her 3 sons back in the 70s because if she didn't, they would get penile cancer. And if you can believe it, that myth is still around!
I'd love for everyone to post their best evidence to the contrary (arguments about human rights always welcome, too!)
Circumcision is the removal of a part or all of the foreskin at birth or later on in life. This practice has been suggested as conferring some protection against cancer of the penis by contributing to improved hygiene. However, the penile cancer risk is low in some uncircumcised populations, and the practice of circumcision is strongly associated with socio-ethnic factors which in turn are associated with lessened risk. The consensus among studies that have taken these other factors into account is that circumcision is not of value in preventing cancer of the penis. It is important that the issue of circumcision not distract the public's attention from avoiding known penile cancer risk factors -- having unprotected sexual relations with multiple partners (increasing the likelihood of human papillomavirus infection) and cigarette smoking.
They list "not being circumcised" as a risk, but the section really doesn't add any new information. The "Cleanliness, Phimosis, and Smegma" section and "HPV" sections cover it. Phimosis can make it harder for a man to wash and cleanliness is a factor in penile cancer. So, treat the phimosis conservatively with stretching and steroid cream, not circumcision.
In summary, penile cancer is a very rare cancer. If you are seriously concerned about it, advise your son to wash regularly, avoid STDs and HIV through safe sex practices, and don't smoke. Consider the HPV vaccine when it is available for males. Circumcision will really make no difference.
Each of the tissues in the penis contains several types of cells. Different types of penile cancer (cancer of the penis) can develop in each kind of cell. The differences are important because they determine the seriousness of the cancer and the type of treatment needed.
Epidermoid carcinoma: Penile cancer develops in the skin of the penis. About 95% of penile cancers develop from flat skin cells called squamous cells. Penile tumors tend to grow slowly. If they are found at an early stage, these tumors can usually be cured. Squamous cell penile cancers can develop anywhere on the penis but most develop on the foreskin (in men who have not been circumcised) or on the glans.
Penile cancer is extremely rare in the United States and accounts
for less than one half a percent of cancers diagnosed among men
and less than one tenth of a percent of cancer deaths among men.
.....
However, the penile cancer risk is low in some uncircumcised
populations, and the practice of circumcision is strongly associated
with socio-ethnic factors, which in turn are associated with lessened
risk. The consensus among studies that have taken these other
factors into account is circumcision is not of value in preventing
cancer of the penis.
Proven penile cancer risk factors include having unprotected sexual
relations with multiple partners (increasing the likelihood of
human papillomavirus infection), and cigarette smoking.
Originally Posted by mamasophy;8977579I don't have the stats, but they're on the same site: [B
vulvar cancer [/B]is also more common than penile cancer.
Good to know. Statistics like these help put things in perspective.
The ACS predicts that in 2007, 3490 cases of vulvar cancer will be reported and 880 women will die from it.
Wouldn't penile cancer be rampant in Europe if that was the case??? That is what I told my folks and they didn't have a comeback for that one.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Mothering Forum
16.5M posts
285.2K members
Since 1996
A forum community dedicated to all mothers and inclusive family living enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about nurturing, health, behavior, housing, adopting, care, classifieds, and more!