Mothering Forum banner

Critique my letter to the hospital please!!!!

636 Views 14 Replies 13 Participants Last post by  bell bottom blues
My DS is 4 1/2 months old and I FINALLY got around to writing a letter to the hospital I delivered at. I need everyone's opinion. Please tell me if I should add anything, change anything, or take anything out. Don't be afraid to tell me if there are grammatical or spelling errors. I want to sound as intelligent as possible. :LOL

To whom it may concern:

I recently gave birth to a beautiful baby boy at X Hospital. Upon being admitted, I was asked a series of questions pertaining to my health care and my upcoming stay. Among those questions, I was asked if I wanted my baby circumcised if it was a boy. I said "no" and the nurse entered my answer into the computer.

After the delivery and after being moved to a post-partum recovery room, I tried to relax with my son. However, my stay was anything but relaxing. You see, whenever there was a shift change, a new doctor would come into my room and ask if I wanted my son circumcised. The first night in the recovery room, at about 10:00 pm, a doctor came in and, since I was asleep, asked my PARENTS if I wanted my baby circumcised. If the doctor had checked my chart, he would have known the answer to that question. What bothers me more though, is that he asked someone other than the mother of the child. What would have happened if my mother mistakenly said, "yes"? I assume the doctor would have woken me to sign a consent form, and being exhausted from labor, I may have unintentionally signed it. If something like that had happened, I would have failed as a mother on my son's first day outside my womb. If my son had been circumcised against my wishes, I would have been absolutely devastated.

The second night, I asked the nurse when I would be discharged the next day. She responded by saying, "Well, he (my son) hasn't had his circumcision, yet, sooo...." My heart skipped a beat. I interuppted her and very strongly said, "He's NOT being circumcised!" She looked at me incredulously and asked "Never!?" "NEVER," was my reply. Because the circumcision rates are close to 50% in America now, I was shocked that this nurse thought it was strange to not circumcise. She was obviously not educated on this subject.

The rest of my stay at your hospital, I was a nervous wreck. Everytime someone took my son from the room, I asked why, exactly, they were taking him and everytime, upon his return, I would check his diaper to make sure his penis was not wrapped in bloody gauze.

I wanted to let you know that I am 110% against circumcision and I was 110% sure that I didn't want my son to be circumcised. Unfortunately, this decision does not come as easily to many parents. I'm afraid that the doctors and nurses at X Hospital are giving the wrong impression to new parents. I've researched circumcision extensively, but sadly, many parents do not research it at all. Some parents talk with their doctors only to find out that, "it's not medically necessary," and base their decision soley on that, all the while, everyone else is telling them to do it because its "cleaner" and "better looking". They don't have the education to respond to pressure accordingly.

My point is, if a new mother has made the decision to leave her son intact, the hospital should not be giving her the impression that she made the wrong choice. The hospital should be 110% supportive of her decision. Routine infant circumcision is not recommended by any health organization. Societal pressure to circumcise our sons still exists strongly in America. In order to change that, we must start with the medical community.

I hope that in the future, X Hospital will take the time to educate it's doctors and nurses about routine infant circumcision so that parents do not feel pressured to sign the consent form.

Sincerely,
Shauna M. X
See less See more
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
I think the letter is good. Be sure to send it to the hospitals board of directors.
Quote:
I interuppted her and very strongly said, "He's NOT being circumcised!"
interrupted

Quote:
Some parents talk with their doctors only to find out that, "it's not medically necessary," and base their decision soley on that, all the while, everyone else is telling them to do it because its "cleaner" and "better looking". They don't have the education to respond to pressure accordingly.
solely

Quote:
My point is, if a new mother has made the decision to leave her son intact, the hospital should not be giving her the impression that she made the wrong choice.
I'd remove "My point is" and leave it at "If a new mother has made the decision...."
See less See more
Shauna,

First off, I applaud you for writing this letter. I have a few suggestions, but don't get me wrong. It's already very well written. I'm just sorry that you had to go through all that.

On to the nitpicking (and feel free to ignore any and all suggestions
):

1. I agree w/ all of Simplicity's suggestions.

2. In the 4th paragraph (ignoring the "To whom it may concern" line), replace the two instances of everytime (1 word) w/ every time (2 words).

3. In the last paragraph, replace "it's" w/ its.

4. Here's a possible rewrite for the 5th and 6th paragraphs. Sorry I got on the soapbox at the end.

I have extensively researched circumcision, and as a result, I am 110% against it and was 110% sure that I did not want my son to be circumcised. Sadly, many parents do not research circumcision at all. Some parents may talk with their doctors, but at best are only told that it's "not medically necessary", all the while hearing from everyone else that it's "cleaner" and "better looking". When coupled with my own experience at Hospital X, it's easy, yet unfortunate, to see why many parents choose to circumcise their sons.

If parents have made the decision to leave their son intact, the hospital should be 110% supportive of this decision. The hospital should not make them feel as though they made the wrong choice, yet, by constantly questioning a parent's decision to NOT circumcise, this is exactly what the doctors and nurses of X Hospital are doing. Societal pressure to circumcise still exists strongly in the United States even though routine infant circumcision is not recommended by any health organization. For this to change, the medical community must take the lead by educating itself so that it may better serve [or help, aid, etc.] those it is supposed to care for and protect.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaunam

I wanted to let you know that I am 110% against circumcision and I was 110% sure that I didn't want my son to be circumcised. Unfortunately, this decision does not come as easily to many parents. I'm afraid that the doctors and nurses at X Hospital are giving the wrong impression to new parents. I've researched circumcision extensively, but sadly, many parents do not research it at all. Some parents talk with their doctors only to find out that, "it's not medically necessary," and base their decision soley on that, all the while, everyone else is telling them to do it because its "cleaner" and "better looking". They don't have the education to respond to pressure accordingly.

My point is, if a new mother has made the decision to leave her son intact, the hospital should not be giving her the impression that she made the wrong choice. The hospital should be 110% supportive of her decision. Routine infant circumcision is not recommended by any health organization. Societal pressure to circumcise our sons still exists strongly in America. In order to change that, we must start with the medical community.
See less See more
The only thing that I could add is to put something in it that this constant questioning amounts to solicitation for the procedure and that a meeting of the staff should be held or that a memo go out to all neonatal personnel that employees should not be asking about the procedure since it's already been entered on the medical records. They should check the chart instead of repeatedly asking. This puts too much pressure on the mother at a vulnerable time.

Frank

PS: I suspect if I were in the position and were asked a second time, my reaction would be so strong that word would quickly spread around the hospital and no one would dare ask me again!
:
See less See more
Everyone has made great suggestions.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frankly Speaking
PS: I suspect if I were in the position and were asked a second time, my reaction would be so strong that word would quickly spread around the hospital and no one would dare ask me again!
I made it adamantly clear before Jett's surgery to the surgeons and the one nurse who would accompany him continually until I was with him again that he was not to be retracted, circumcised or even changed by anyone but her. He came back to with a new diaper, changed once by the good, attentive nurse, which was fine. Every time a nurse or attendant walked in our PICU room, they said, "You're doing all the diaper changes, right?" Word got around quickly that Jett was 'potty trained' (we EC) and that we used cloth diapers and were the most attentive, positive parents they had seen. Everyone asked questions and complimented us. It was amazing. There are good medical staff out there. I just wish they weren't so damned rare.
See less See more
thanks for doing what i couldnt do. i too was asked several times if we wanted nathan circed. it was in teh computer, but apparently noone wrote it on his chart the times we were asked
i like it. but science/math people tend to get to eye-rolling about people who say things like '110%'. 100% pretty much covers it.

other than that, it's great.

suse
Quote:

Originally Posted by suseyblue
i like it. but science/math people tend to get to eye-rolling about people who say things like '110%'. 100% pretty much covers it.

other than that, it's great.

suse
That's what my DH said, too, so I will probably change it. I've always used 110% for emphasis and in this case, the 100%=me not wanting my son circ'ed and the extra 10% is for the vomit that tries to escape my body when I think about circ. :LOL

I hope that makes sense.

And to everyone else, thanks for the suggestions. I'm revising it now. And thanks for catching the spelling mistakes. I didn't catch all of them when I re-read it.

"When coupled with my own experience at Hospital X, it's easy, yet unfortunate, to see why many parents choose to circumcise their sons."

I was going to put something like that in there, put didn't know how to word it, so thanks!
See less See more
I just wanted to say that I think it is so sad how many times you were asked. This yet again confirms the lack of care in hospitals. And yet again confirms why I want a homebirth so much.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaunam
.
Routine infant circumcision is not recommended by any health organization. Societal pressure to circumcise our sons still exists strongly in America. In order to change that, we must start with the medical community.
I applaud your letter. The only suggestion I have is that from taking a profesional writing class we were told to stick to one subject and not cloud the message with our own personal opinion if possible. I think everything sounded good I would just maybe rethink the few sentences that educate them on why not to circumcise. The point of your letter is their constant nagging and banter of why you chose not to cicumcise and there hospital policy. I feel that if you go into a learning seminar they may just look at it as a letter from a disgruntled mom who is opposing them performing circ's. While you may want them to realize how uneducated they are I think the point will still come across in the end. I realize it may be hard to tame down your opinion and emotions on this subject but I would direct it more with their hospital policy and constant banter. It will sound a lot more professional for you to just state that you did not want your son circ and was repeatedly questioned why, then to go off on why you didn't want him to be circ'. Does this make sense?
See less See more
I dunno, I think I'd go off on another paragraph about informed consent and how, in addition to badgering you over and over again, they didn't attempt to explain the procedure, the "potential benefits", the many risks, the recommendations of major medical organizations, etc. I mean sheesh, when I was in the hospital they made me read a brochure and sign that I'd read it about why not to shake a baby (um, DUH, anyone? Yeah, I know it happens, but don't we all know it's BAD?). Shouldn't circ policy be AT LEAST this strict? Fwiw, I had a girl, and everyone I've known who's birthed there has too (something in the water?
), so I don't know how this particular hospital deals with that.

But maybe Starr's right; that might detract from your original letter. Write two. :LOL
See less See more
Good for you! If more of us(meaning me :LOL) would get off of our lazy butts and do the same thing just imagine the impact it would have!

I had a similar experience, not as drastic but i was asked 3 times in less than 24 hours if I wanted my baby cut, but never got around to writing that letter.....you just might have inspied me


Take care!
Tara
See less See more
2
I wouldn't worry about too many issues, in fact I'd add something about being concerned that the hospital was opening itself up to legal trouble by having the staff *solicit* unnecessary surgery.
I don't have anything to add to the other suggestions. However, I'm wondering if it might be a good idea to talk to John Geisheker, the legal counsel for Doctors Opposing Circumcision - not to critique your letter, which is awesome - but he might also write a letter to them. If they got two letters - one from a parent and one from an attorney - they might take even more notice and make some changes.

His whole job is to advocate against circumcision anywhere and everywhere. He writes tons of letters like this, pretty much anytime anyone asks him to and it's appropriate. (And, of course, he never charges a dime.)

I love your letter, and the fact that you're writing it.

Maybe it would even be a good idea to post it as a sticky so that other moms can use it as a template to write their own letters to hospitals that unduly pressured them?

Just my thoughts,
See less See more
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top