Mothering Forum banner

Cutting off the Cable, How to tell him?

961 Views 17 Replies 16 Participants Last post by  tpintsch
Our family has cable tv and over the past few months we have seen behaviors in DS (age 7) that are starting to bother us. He has an attitude problem, he's starting to be disrespectful, he parrots advertizements at us all the time, the list goes on. I have tried limiting his exposure, making him work for it, setting up parental controls, but the reality is that I'm not discplined enough to make it stick. So, because of all that DH and I have made the choice to turn off the cable. What is the best way to break it to DS. Should it just happen and let it be a suprise? Should I prepare him for it before it happens? What do you think is the best way for him to find out?
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
I would tell him something like "We've decided to cancel the cable service. We don't think the extra channels were a good idea. It'll be nice and warm out soon and we'll be spending a lot of time outside." I'd try to spin it positively instead of focusing on the negative.
I would just flat out tell him. Or, just wait until he notices that it's off and say nonchalantly like, " oh yeah, we cancelled it," or something like that. Don't make it a big deal.
Quote:

Originally Posted by dearmama22 View Post
I would just flat out tell him. Or, just wait until he notices that it's off and say nonchalantly like, " oh yeah, we cancelled it," or something like that. Don't make it a big deal.

Yeah, that's what we would do.
See less See more
Honestly, and I've had this problem with my kids, we turn it off and tell them no. We havent' had to cut our cable or go passive on it, we flat out told them that due to their behavior their TV time was being cut down and they would have to earn it back with good attitudes and by helping out extra around the house.
My ex signed us up for cable when I was out of town and we couldn't afford it so they shut it off when we couldn't pay the bill. dd was about three-ish and a big teevee fan, but I don't think she was traumatized.I told her ahead of time that the man was coming on such-and-such day to turn off the cable because we couldn't afford it and she was a bit confused and expected him to take the actual device as well,but she didn't cry or act rude or anything.

We went on to become TV free and like it much better this way.
See less See more
In a very young child (age 2-3) I'd be OK with just shutting off and explaining when it's noticed. However, a 7 year old deserves some warning/explaination. I know my 4 yo would be confused and asking a million questions about it. I just think giving several warnings and talks about it is the gentle thing to do. I'd start discussing it during the last month and giving reminders every few days about what to expect once it's gone. It's kinda like when my kids are playing at the park. . it never goes over well when I just swoop in and say "We're going home NOW!". I get much more cooperation when I count down ". . in 10 minutes", ". . .in 5 minutes", etc.
We had cable for a few months when I was around that age, and my mom had it turned off for reasons similar to yours. She didn't sugarcoat it and told us exactly why she made the decision. At the time I was probably a little sad, but I got over it quickly. No lifetime scars.
And as an adult, I actually have a lot of respect for her for doing it.
See less See more
I'd just be like, "Oh. Huh. It's broken. Wanna come do XYZ?"

My stepkids are coming back to visit for the summer and I am SO GLAD we don't get Nick, Noggin, Disney, the N, and Cartoon Network anymore!!! IF I NEVER HAVE TO WATCH SPONGEBOB AGAIN, IT WILL BE TOO SOON.

I don't care how much they complain, they can go play with rocks in the dirt like normal eight year olds.

~Rose
Quote:

Originally Posted by MonAmiBella View Post
Honestly, and I've had this problem with my kids, we turn it off and tell them no. We havent' had to cut our cable or go passive on it, we flat out told them that due to their behavior their TV time was being cut down and they would have to earn it back with good attitudes and by helping out extra around the house.
I really have tried that, but I am a giant pushover and my son, he is very convincing when he wants something, and at this point it would just be easier to get rid of the cable then have a constant battle over it. I grew up without cable and so did DH. I believe I grew up to be a better adult without it even though I resented my parents for not letting me watch whatever was popular at the time.

It was a tough decision for us, I really think the whole family is addicted to television right now.

I think we are just going to tell him a few days before but put a positive spin on it. I have a feeling he is going to be so bummed.
See less See more
We don't have tv but we do use our computers to watch a few things. That way we keep the advertisements to a minimum. Sometimes we'll find ourselves relying on it for entertainment too much and we'll just tell the kids "We think the family is watching too many shows right now and it has not been good for us. We're going to take a break and limit it a bit more since we think it will be healthier and better for the family to find other things to do."

However, if it makes you feel any better, our 7 yo dd is often rude and disrespectful and chooses to antagonize her family when she's bored. Some days she's pretty obnoxious. In between, she's an absolute joy but those other times leave me questioning my parenting skills a lot. So, anyway, cutting out the cable certainly won't hurt but perhaps the behavior is common at this age. We can hope, and look forward to them growing out of it right?
I have teenagers and we're thinking of doing the same thing. Not because they watch too much TV, but because it's just a way to save a few dollars.

Unfortunately, we have a contract with Verizon FIOS until November or so, so we'll have to wait or pay a huge cancellation fee.

I'm thinking it might not go over too well at first, until I remind them that most of what they watch can be seen online or gotten through Netflix.
2
Quote:

Originally Posted by tpintsch View Post
I really have tried that, but I am a giant pushover and my son, he is very convincing when he wants something, and at this point it would just be easier to get rid of the cable then have a constant battle over it. I grew up without cable and so did DH. I believe I grew up to be a better adult without it even though I resented my parents for not letting me watch whatever was popular at the time.

It was a tough decision for us, I really think the whole family is addicted to television right now.

I think we are just going to tell him a few days before but put a positive spin on it. I have a feeling he is going to be so bummed.
I completely understand and sympathize. For your sake, as a parent, I agree that getting rid of cable is the right thing to do.

How to tell him? Just tell him, casually, as if it's just a fact, no biggy. Because that's all it is. He might be picking up on your anxiety and mommy guilt.

I would have canceled cable 10 years ago, except that dh says that's not fair to him. And he's right. He works long days, don't watch hours and hours of tv, and he just wants to watch a show or two before we go to bed.

Don't be afraid of your kid's emotions, Tpintsch.
See less See more
Tv is bad when the kid makes it a life. I think I'd tell him why he doesn't have cable anymore.
I would just say "Dad and I have decided that having cable isn't the best thing for our family right now so we are having it shut off, I know you really like to watch shows but now we will have more time to do x,y,z things." Also, are you in a financial position where you could take the money you were spending on cable and use it for a fun family outing every month or put towards a more positive hobby for DS?
Are you willing to lose Cable? Or is it just the childs behavior? I ask because there are things *I* like about cable that i am not willing to lose because of the kids behavior, however, I have flat out told my kids they are NOT watching tv because of their behavior and since they are not the ones who pay for it, they are NOT the ones who decide what is on TV. I control it all and during the week, my kids (well the two younger ones) don't watch tv at all. On the weekends, they are So busy that they don't watch more then an hour. i am sure once summer gets here thy will watch more (it is over 110 here in the summer) but right now it is too nice outside.

My oldest watches tv with me. What ever I watch. Which usually is just the network stations, but I have DVR and I do like animal planet and some of the cable stations.
I know two separate families who got cats and used the "saved" cable/ game system money to pay for the cats' care. That does seem a little extreme though.
See less See more
4
Quote:

Originally Posted by lolar2 View Post
I know two separate families who got cats and used the "saved" cable/ game system money to pay for the cats' care. That does seem a little extreme though.


We already have 3 cats, I think I would go nuts if we had more. (I know you were just stating an example)


I really like the idea of taking some of the money we save from cable and using it on other fun things. We LOVE going to the drive-in on weekends. I think that's how I will spin it to him anyway.

As far as punishing ourselves with no cable, it will definantly be an adjustment. But we are going to still have network channels, and most of the shows DH and I watch are on network anyway. I will definantly miss shows like Discovery Earth and Blue Planet. I'm also looking forward to spending actual time with DH that doesn't involve staring at the box. I just have to think of the positive side effects I suppose. I've really gotten to hate how DS is starting to sound like iCarly.
See less See more
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top