Mothering Forum banner

Ds plays so different from other tots...is it strange?

788 Views 15 Replies 15 Participants Last post by  LizD
I have started to take ds (now 23 months) to a local playtime at our community center. They have lots of soft blocks and mats, a soft slide, tunnels, etc for running around and tumbling. All the other kids run and jump and tumble around, but ds is content to just gather up all the balls and put them into one place, or gather up all these little plastic toys and line them up, then methodically move them one by one to another place and so on. He doesn't want to run or climb like the other kids. I know it's not fair to compare one kid to the next, but I have never seen a child this young who doesn't want to run around. I encourage him to climb up the blocks and slide down the slide, but I don't push or force, and he just states that he doesn't want to, even though this is the perfect opportunity for him to get some tumble time in. I'm starting to think he is so cautious and "nerdy" already since he seems to prefer to engage his mind more than his body. Anyone else have a child like this? I don't want to put ds into a box, but it just seems like he doesn't want to do what most kids I know his age prefer to do.
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
i think it's important to let him do what he wants and to be himself.
if his development is on track, i wouldn't worry about his preferences. what if he turns out to be a genius? will you still be sorry that he doesn't like to do what other people like to do?
i would just keep a close eye on his developmental milestones, social, physical, etc. if those are coming along normally (even if behind his age, if he is progressing reasonably), then i wouldn't worry about him being who he wants to be.

See less See more
DD is the same way (at 18 mo though). She prefers to move toys from one location to another, over and over again. She also likes to climb, but not as much as her "toy organization". Maybe they should get together and play! LOL
3
Quote:

Originally Posted by LeosMama
i think it's important to let him do what he wants and to be himself.
if his development is on track, i wouldn't worry about his preferences. what if he turns out to be a genius? will you still be sorry that he doesn't like to do what other people like to do?
i would just keep a close eye on his developmental milestones, social, physical, etc. if those are coming along normally (even if behind his age, if he is progressing reasonably), then i wouldn't worry about him being who he wants to be.


Great post so I'll ditto the whole thing
Not all kids like to run around and jump, some are more cautious. Maybe he'll be some great architect or something cool like that


As long as he's progressing normally I wouldn't worry.
See less See more
My DD is not a terribly active kid either. She doesn't really do a whole lot of running and climbing. She CAN, but it's just not her favorite way to spend her time. She much prefers carrying around and playing with her stuffed toys and dolls, and quieter activities like container play and looking at books and stuff. I know she's okay because my MIL says DH was the same way, and he's fine. Each kid is different. I know what you mean about feeling strange about it, though-- I used to take DD to Gymboree and I felt like people thought she was weird for preferring sitting on my lap with a doll to climbing on all the apparatus.
My older son was the same at that age. We did Gymboree, where all the other kids would gleefully run and go through tunnels and do whatever physical tasks they were asked to do. My son was the only kid who didn't do this. He would watch the other kids (sometimes clapping for them), inspect the shapes on the stairs while kids were practically climbing over him and make me carry him around so he could study the pictures on the walls. He really stood out at 1 and 2, esp as a boy. He was very quiet, cautious and deliberate. My younger son is not like that at all.

FWIW, my older son became more physical as he got older. It's different for boys, because they get a testosterone surge around 4; that's when we noticed him becoming more of a physical, active person. He is still cautious and deliberate though. That's just his personality.
It's still a 50/50 as to whether he'll feel like going down the slide at the park.

I know exactly what you describe about noticing how different your child is. I think it's harder when it's your first. I knew mine was different and it just really confused me and concerned me for a while. I ruled out other possible issues (e.g. Asperger's) and could only come up with, "It's just him." Enjoy your child; he sounds wonderful.
See less See more
My ds is alot like LeftField explain in her older ds. My ds was much more deliberate, scrutinizing, and would overall prefer to "take things in" vs running around like a wild man when he was your ds's age. Now, at just 2.5yo, he's much more active, will go down slides and overall interact with other kids great. But, he still likes to watch kids, try to figure out how things work and what they are. It's very much his personality. So, like everyone has said, if your ds is pregressing normally, I would not be concerned.
This is kind of funny for me because I often wonder if my kids are normal since they both like to run and jump so much. Seriously, they are never still. They aren't very good at imaginative play, they only listen to books if it is bedtime. I feel like I am doomed to be the mother of 2 jocks (dh and I are much more intellectual than athletic). So I guess no matter what side you are on, any extreme makes you wonder.
Thanks to the replies so far. It is nice to know that ds isn't so "odd" and other toddlers play like him too. I have yet to meet another toddler who can engage in such quiet, imaginative play (he already has an imaginary friend and pretends his food are diggers and trucks and dinosaurs before eating it) and not run and jump around so much. He is either right on target or "ahead" in his developement/milestones and is very good at interacting with people, so I am not concerned about that. I just worry sometimes because I am like that and I spent most of my childhood feeling odd and left out and sad. The snow is melting here, so yesterday we went to the park to go on the slide, swings, etc...and all he wanted to do was play with the gravel and sticks. I'm sure it was fun for him, but booooooooring for me. hahaha. I want to encourage him to be more physical because I have read that the more a child runs/jumps/climbs when they are young, the more agile they are when they are adults. I don't know if that is true or not. I am just happy to hear others with the same play habits as ds. Thanks.
See less See more
Another one here with a ds with a quieter nature. Funnily enough I had a moment myself today when I thought 'he just doesn't seem like other babies' (he's 13 months but not walking so seems somewhere between baby and toddler at the moment!)

I was dancing around with him singing along to music. I was having a great time but he just wasn't entertained by it at all. When I try excitedly throwing him in the air a little he just gets a slightly shocked look but just doesn't enjoy that kind of play. What he really prefers is sitting down and taking blocks out of his wooden house and handing them to me, then putting them all back again!

My sister was concerned that I might think she doesn't give my ds enough 'baby type' interaction but she said that he's just not into it and he'd rather just crawl over, have a cuddle and 'chat' a little with her which is true. I guess some kids just do have these personalities but it is nice to hear about others.
See less See more
We had a program like this at the local Y. Ds loved it the first time we were there and after that he just wanted to get out or eat or drink but could care less about the toys all the other kids were going to town on. He like the bowling pin set and to put bean bags in a net. BUT - at one point I said to him "let's go play basketball with Adam." He went to the basketball hoop, picked up the ball and made a basket. He didn't really care about playing with that toy but he knew what was going on.
I and all of my siblings were "thing people" growing up. We were not runners, jumpers, or socializers - we could not be happier than sitting with a box of buttons and sorting them by color, size, etc.... things of that nature were what we loved.
There is nothing wrong with that, it's just a different type of kid.
OP-This is my DD to a T. She has always been like this. She is very sweet, shy, sensitive and would prefer to play by herself..She loves arranging and has been doing table puzzles since forever. I remember being so much like her when I was young.
I just say she is who she is
See less See more
2
I haven't read what all the previous posters wrote, but here's my 2-cents.

I wouldn't worry about it either. As someone above mentioned, I'd keep an eye on the developmental milestones, but if he's capable of running, jumping, etc and perhaps prefers not to when in a huge group of kids, that's fine. Not all kids warm up to playtimes with huge groups of other kids. Some love to run and play with the others, some prefer to be quiet and hoard toys. My DS fluctuates between the two. Some days he is out there running and climbing with everyone else, and some days he brings me all the toys and just wants me to hold onto them. When he's with a very familiar group of kids in a familiar place, he's much more likely to run and play and interact, but when we're in a new place or somewhere that's really active and crowdded, he's much more likely to stay close to me and play quietly. But I'm the same way so I totally understand!


Keep going and before long he may open right up, or not, as long as he's having fun and it's not a terrible experience.


lizabird
See less See more
2
My son was the type to like to play on his own that way too. He did it when in preschool from age 3-4. He was an only child still at that time so I think that had a lot to do with it, plus he has always been a very quiet and shy child. He still is now at 10 years old although he does know how to go out and talk to kids his age and play with them now. He started getting better about it when he turned school age.


I would just let your child be and let him do what he feels best doing. My second child has been more of the type to run and jump and join in with the others very quickly, total opposite of her big brother. She has a totally different personality.
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by bass chick
it just seems like he doesn't want to do what most kids I know his age prefer to do.
There really isn't "most kids his age prefer..." - by the time you turn around you might be wondering if his IQ is ok because he used to play like this and now won't sit still. Some of it is personality, and some of it is development; that's most interesting to him right now, because it's terribly exciting to be able to mass objects and sort them and organize them. As long as major development issues are nothing to worry about enjoy your baby for who s/he is. They really do change so much, and there's a different definition of "normal" for every single child.
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top