Mothering Forum banner
1 - 8 of 8 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
27 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Last night was the knock-down-drag-out version of what was before a mildly amusing/ somewhat annoying behavior. After tonight, we must take a stand. But I am not sure what that stand should be, but we can't let her keep getting her own way with which one of us she wants at any given moment.

For the past week, she has preferred DH, I think, because he is the novelty home all week on spring break. When he is working FT, she prefers me. She has now started full out screaming for the other parent when the parent she does not want approaches. Really, her screams are oscar worthy. We are both equally gentle and firm when necessary. For the screaming at the reject-parent, we put her in time out in her crib. She just screamed to get out. I am not so convinced she gets why she was there.

She is an only, so there is no concept of sharing or wait your turn. We pretty much come when she needs us. She likes to be in the middle. She even sometimes gets upset when DH and I hug if she is not in the middle of it. Not always, but if she is sitting with one of us and the other one comes to cuddle, she will sometimes push the other parent away.

I do not want to raise her to think that her every whim will be honored. We respect her choices/ wants. We don't force affection. I am very big in this. You can say sorry without giving a kiss/ hug. I think kids need to have their own physical and emotional boundaries respected. Even the irrational ones they have at 2. But at the same time, DD does not get a say in who wipes her hands and face after she is done eating. This is what she was screaming at me about tonight. She wanted DH. And then the diaper change was the same thing. This I will not indulge. We just can't. It isn't practical.

I do not want to tolerate the growling (? for lack of a better description) and crying and screaming that ensues when the un-parent-of-the-moment approaches to wipe hands/ change diaper/ change clothes. We have too many things to get done in a day to indulge this. She gets her way 98% if the time. I feel like this is a line I have to hold or my life will be ruled by my 2 y.o.

Maybe it is all in my head, but I can see myself becoming resentful and bitter towards DD when she acts like this. Usually I just have empathy for her when she is having a difficult moment. Now I am starting to resent her when she acts like this. I want some in-the-line-of-fire parenting options: leave her in her high chair until she will tolerate being wiped? Put her in time out? BOTH parents leave the room she is in so she is by herself? (This is a problem we have when both DH and I are present. When it is just one of us, it is not an issue.) I want something that says, "We will not tolerate this behavior" without leaving causing her emotional trauma.

How do parents handle the temper tantrum and sometimes aggressive displays when DC want one parent over another?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,385 Posts
Well we really try to honour DS voice. When he is "asking" for one of us over the other and we have the ability to honour this (when the parent he is asking for is able to come or help him) then we do. If we can not, like if he wants DH to wipe his hands but I am there and DH is busy or downstairs or unable to then I say to him as I am wiping his hands "I know you wanted dada to wipe your hands but he can't right now so mama is going to help you", or I offer him to do it himself. If he screams and hollers and is upset I try really hard to stay calm and show him that I love him unconditionally and label his emotions "You are upset, mad, sad, etc that mama is helping you and not dada. I know it is hard when you can't have what you want." I will also break out my silliest face, song, dance whatever to help break the tension and try to distract him till I am done doing what needs to be done.

In terms of the pushing hitting other parent away. I say "please don't hurt mama, are you trying to tell me you want some space? say space please"

I really feel strongly that using love withdrawl does not teach a child anything except that they are loved conditional (they are love when they are doing/being what the parent wants) A great book to read is Unconditional Parenting by Alfie Kohn. Of course sometimes we need to step away to compose ourselves and calm down so that we can be the loving, reasuring, strong parent that our children expect and need this is different then withdrawing to "teach" a child how to behave.

Good luck toddlers are wonderfully fun but can be extremely challenging and hard to parent sometimes that is why it is great to have resources to turn to.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
758 Posts
I agree with the pp about not using "love withdrawal". Frustration is a normal part of life...whether the parent you want is not available and the "unparent" is wiping your hands OR your child is acting in a noncooperative way. So how you hande your frustration will be the model for how your child handles hers. I sometimes get upset because I don't want my child to feel frustrated or upset ... but this is impossible and impractical. What we need to accomplish as parents is modeling behavior to deal with frustration, disappointment, sadness, anger, and hope that our child learns the necessary skills. I try to be firm without being mean. If hands need to be wiped, then that must happen. If it's not practical for the desired parent to do it, then it still needs to be done. And it's ok for your child to be unhappy about it. As pp pointed out, you can teach your child to put their disappointment into words and one day they will use words instead of screaming. Until then...screaming is ok
IMHO!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
523 Posts
BubbeSue, I could have written your post a few months ago! We also have an only dd (2 1/2) and when she started this behavior, dh and I decided we would just not tolerate it and help her work through it.

Six months later, after some very frustrating moments, we have reversed course. It had led to an unreasonable amount of tension in the house and really affected all of us in a negative way. We decided to honor dd's requests, as long as she did so in a respectful way (no hitting, screaming, etc.). If I am at home, i do the things she needs help with like pottying, shoe tying, etc. If I feel like I need a break, then I leave the house, and she does just fine with dh when I'm not around.

We've noticed that her requests are fading and she is now asking for dh almost as much as she is for me. It's like stopping the fight just helped her get over it sooner. I have chalked it up to a normal toddler's need to control a situation as much as possible, and if I can help her be respectful when asking for who/what she needs, then I feel like I am helping her.
HTH!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,687 Posts
DD is 23 months and is going through a bit of this. I think it may be to a lesser extent than you deal with because we both (DH and I) work outside the home and therefore DD gets one-on-one time with each of us, wether she likes it or not.

We do not tolerate hitting in our house. If DD doesn't want me to do xyz and would prefer daddy, that's fine, but there will be no hitting. We have to explain a few times a day that hitting is not ok, but she's getting it. We also fill in the gap for her by telling her was IS ok "no hitting please, that hurts, if you would like xyz then you can ask for it nicely "I would like xyz please".".

One of our biggest battles is bedtime this week. DH has been home in the evening for a few weeks now, he usually works from 3pm-3am so bedtime is up to me most nights. I calmly remind DD that daddy is not available right now and that mommy needs to brush her teeth, change her clothes, put on her diaper, etc etc etc. There is nothing wrong with telling your child that it's not thier choice who is to do something for them when that choice isn't convenient for you. You're right that she shouldn't get her way ALL the time, kids need to learn to live with dissappointment. However, pick your battles wisely
Sometimes your own dissappointment is easier to live with and gets you through the day a lot saner!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,887 Posts
Not sure how verbal she is - but if she can ask nicely even if tha tjust means signing 'more' and saying dada - then fine, give her to dada. But if its all screaming and crying - nope. I carry on doing just what I was doing - changing a dipe, whatever.

It is normal for kids to go through phases of preferring mom or dad - all 3 of mine have done that. But the throwing a fit about it wouldnt be put up with.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
3,220 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by kdtmom2be View Post
DD is 23 months and is going through a bit of this. I think it may be to a lesser extent than you deal with because we both (DH and I) work outside the home and therefore DD gets one-on-one time with each of us, wether she likes it or not.

We do not tolerate hitting in our house. If DD doesn't want me to do xyz and would prefer daddy, that's fine, but there will be no hitting. We have to explain a few times a day that hitting is not ok, but she's getting it. We also fill in the gap for her by telling her was IS ok "no hitting please, that hurts, if you would like xyz then you can ask for it nicely "I would like xyz please".".

One of our biggest battles is bedtime this week. DH has been home in the evening for a few weeks now, he usually works from 3pm-3am so bedtime is up to me most nights. I calmly remind DD that daddy is not available right now and that mommy needs to brush her teeth, change her clothes, put on her diaper, etc etc etc. There is nothing wrong with telling your child that it's not thier choice who is to do something for them when that choice isn't convenient for you. You're right that she shouldn't get her way ALL the time, kids need to learn to live with dissappointment. However, pick your battles wisely
Sometimes your own dissappointment is easier to live with and gets you through the day a lot saner!
this is how we have been handling DD and she is 24 months this friday.
 
1 - 8 of 8 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top