Mothering Forum banner
1 - 14 of 14 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
1,790 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
DH and I are thinking about purchasing a hybrid car. With the way gas prices are right now and his commute to work (new job=better pay=longer commute) We'd be going down to one car if we do this~
Tell me pros/cons...
Help me to decide if this is a good option for us or if we just need a more fuel efficient car!
Thanks
 

· Registered
Joined
·
528 Posts
i have two friends who have a prius. they both say they get around 35 mpg, realistically.

We just bought a Scion XB and we get 32-35 mpg. It has a smaller engine, but that's fine by me. It's also cheaper and roomier....
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
7,106 Posts
I have a Prius and I get 50MPG and its 5 years old!! The thing that makes a hybrid a more efficient choice is how long your trips are. If you are driving 75 MPH on the highway for an hour each way then a Hybrid might not be the best choice for you...but if you are driving in stop and go city traffic for an hour it will get better gas millage than any other car on the market because the engine shuts off instead of idling. Also if your not only concerned about the gas prices but also your personal carbon dioxide foot print on the planet, a hybrid is a great way to reduce it. Plus you get a break on your taxes...the Prius is the highest at $3100 for federal and most states also have a tax deduction. Brings the price down even more if you look at it that way.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,900 Posts
Definitely consider what the commute is to figure which will work out better for you.

I drive a lowly Saturn that gets between 40 and 45 mpg and there are other "regular" cars that do even better. Diesels are also a great choice for fuel efficiency, especially if you go biodiesel.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
9,101 Posts
We have an xb, not a hybrid, but it does get 33/34 mpg. It's $15k brand new and comes pretty stocked w/things that are 'extras' on other cars. If you really can't stand the look of the xb, the xa is about $1000k less and looks more 'traditional'. It's made by toyota, so reliable.

www.scion.com
 

· Registered
Joined
·
6,165 Posts
There are a lot of factors to consider, what are the driving conditions city vs. highway, is gas milage the only issue? You can get "regular" cars that get the same gas miliage, they are cheaper to buy, but harder on the enviroment.......
 

· Registered
Joined
·
246 Posts
Our commuter car is a Jetta TDI which we run on biodiesel. We get 45 miles/gallon average, with city driving and freeway 70 mph driving. Those diesel engines will last forever, and biodiesel is less expensive that petro-diesel in our area. Besides....better for the Earth!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,790 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Can you give me a little more info on bio-diesel? Also we are looking at the Jetta TDI...
Couldn't find anything on the gas mileage, etc.

We're interested in a car that gets good gas mileage and is better for emissions. DH will be driving lots of highway miles.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
246 Posts
Check out www.biodiesel.org, which is a good place to start. It has a retailers map so you can see if anyone retails it in your area. (this is great when you travel with it!) There are 3 stations within 30 miles of our house, but only one is convenient by DH's office. So he just is aware of making sure he fills it once per week when he leaves work on Friday. The nice thing about biodiesel is you can store gas cans in the trunk or garage (we have 5 gallons in each, which is quite a lot of miles on that small car) as an emergency if you can't get to a biodiesel retailer for some reason. Of course, if you're really, really frugal (grin) you could make it in your garage.....I'm sure our neighborhood CCR's say something against that!!

A web search for biodiesel will get you a bunch of other sites also. Green Car Co www.greencarco.com is in our area, but they are a really nice family owned business, and I'm sure if you called them up, they would have some great resources for you and / or discuss TDIs and such. There's probably a bunch of links on their site too.

You may want to consider whether you're buying a Jetta TDI new or used. The VW dealer by us said the warranty is void in the US if you use bio-diesel. We bought ours in 2005, and it's a 2002, so the warranty was pretty much over, so that wasn't an issue for us. I know people who buy new and don't tell the dealer when doing warranty work, but....I don't think I could do that.

We get 45 mpg average, with a bit of city driving and mostly freeway 70-75 mph driving. The freeway by us is 70, so maybe we'd get better mileage if we were driving 60 instead(?).

We _love_ our Jetta. Love it! It's definitely not our family car (I have a 98Toyota Sienna for DD and the furry kids, and it will probably last forever, but we'll replace it with some kind of diesel when it's done.), but DH uses the Jetta to commute and we both use it anytime it's just one of us in the car. It's zippy and I feel safe in it, despite SUVs / Hummers / everything being huge around here.

The only repairs we've had to do in a year+ of a lot of driving is that when we first got it, we had to replace the fuel filter (I think?? DH isn't here to confirm that it was the fuel filter) twice so that it would transition from petro-diesel to bio-diesel. Something about it you don't do that, the two fuels will gunk up together. (Obviously, I just drive my cars vs. repair, right!) It cost us about $75, and we did it immediately upon buying the car and using biodiesel and then about six weeks later. I'm sure someone who knew how to do it could buy the part and replace it themselves for much less.

Hope this helps! It's so fun to drive the Jetta and talk to "strangers who become friends" when they see you're running your car on bio-diesel like they are. Bumper stickers and window decals abound in our area on diesels, all proudly proclaiming Bio-Diesel! Love it, and what a great gift to yourself and future generations.....can't wait until we have two cars on bio-diesel instead of just one!

Happy car shopping,
Karen
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,574 Posts
Just another plug for biodiesel or wvo. The latest ReadyMade magazine has a little article on it. My dad runs their cars on biodiesel. We are saving up for a used Mercedes diesel to make the switch from gas to biodiesel. In the long run, I think it will end up being a lot cheaper and if you do wvo, it's essentially free (if you can find a restaurant resource, the place dh works gives their wvo to someone) Plus, no more guilt about using fossil fuels or pollution from your car!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
723 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by kwarwick
Our commuter car is a Jetta TDI which we run on biodiesel. We get 45 miles/gallon average, with city driving and freeway 70 mph driving. Those diesel engines will last forever, and biodiesel is less expensive that petro-diesel in our area. Besides....better for the Earth!

I agree- get a diesel car and run biodiesel if you can!! We do, but we don't get as good of mileage as kwarwick.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
735 Posts
I dont know anything about biodiesel, but I have a prius.

I love my prius.

for really short trips the milage sucks (like 25, if I am going 4 miles which I did a lot before I moved). but now my husband takes it to work every day. he works about 30 miles away, 55mph most of the way with a few lights. he avrages around 45 miles a gallon. but he also tends to just sit around running the air conditioner while he eats lunch which brings the milage down. when he doesnt do that he gets over 50. sometimes over 75. I tend to avrage around 50. I drove 8 hours on the freeway, and still avraged over 50, sometimes better. I do better with the cruise control on, but my husband gets worse when he does it. I dont know why. there are lots of other great features the prius has that I like (the navigation system for one). but in a few years I might look into biodisel or fuel cell or something else, we'll see........

eta-just looked at that biodisel info page. looks neat. but right it just isnt practile for me. i have no way to get it.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,600 Posts
We drive an Escape Hybrid. We chose it because it's a bigger car with better efficiency. But we chose it for convenience and environmental reasons. Our Honda Civic was fine for our needs, but we wanted bigger. We were not willing to get a gas-guzzling SUV, so we had to go for the Escape Hybrid if we wanted an SUV (we could NOT afford the other Hybrid SUVs). We get better milage with the Escape Hybrid than with the conventional Civic.

I agree with the others; consider all of the aforementioned factors to decide which choice would be right for your family.
 
1 - 14 of 14 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top