Mothering Forum banner

I hate the phrase "broken home".

1388 Views 16 Replies 12 Participants Last post by  jenn s
We were in a broken home before. What we have NOW is not even CLOSE to a broken home. We are quite un-broken, thank you very much.

I HATE the phrase "broken home" to describe single-parent families. Am I the only one?
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Hate it too.
Haven't heard it in awhile though.
Yeah...me too.

Although there's a part of me that recognizes that though our HOME (as in, the happiness and support of our little family) isn't broken, the relationship that started these kids certainly is, so I have respect for the literal language. I just don't like all the connotations attached to it. And also, I blame my ex pretty completely for "breaking" our home (though I appreciate that he did in so many ways!!!), so there's a little vindication in it for me
See less See more
ITA MamaWhit. I prefer to say I escaped a broken home. My home now is full of love; how can that be classified as broken??
I guess I can see where the phrase came from but I don't like how it is used. For example, when a child commits a crime or does something bad, it is usually mention that he/she came from a "broken home" if his or her parents are seperated. It makes it sound like the kid is bad because his or her parents are seperated. But you never hear "broken home" mentioned when a child does something good. I have yet to hear "Jenny won a spelling bee and she is from a broken home". So the phrase seems to have taken on a negative meaning.
Yup. I also hear lots of wives/girlfriends use the phrase when making excuses to not even consider getting out of a horrible relationshipo. Because they don't want to create another broken home.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jilian
I guess I can see where the phrase came from but I don't like how it is used. For example, when a child commits a crime or does something bad, it is usually mention that he/she came from a "broken home" if his or her parents are seperated. It makes it sound like the kid is bad because his or her parents are seperated. But you never hear "broken home" mentioned when a child does something good. I have yet to hear "Jenny won a spelling bee and she is from a broken home". So the phrase seems to have taken on a negative meaning.
This is so true.
Good insight Jilian
that phrase bothers me as well. even tho my stbx and i aren't a family anymore we are BETTER parents then we were before. how is that BROKEN? I like to think of us as a fixed home. cuz we were broken and now we're fixed
See less See more
I think "broken home" is a buzz phrase used to stigmatize people when they get a divorce. It was probably invented by groups that are against divorce.
Just another way to keep women down. If you don't have a man, something is wrong with you. That's society's mentality.

A crap man in the home is better than no man.

We all should know that's crap, divorced or not.

It's the same reason ppl ask women if they're single or divorced. How often do single men get asked that? I don't say I'm divorced, b/c who I am now is not going to be filtered through a man (or lack there-of). I'm single and my home is nice and loving. Thanks!
I really hate that expression too. If your a single parent because a spouse dies, no one says the kids are from a "broken home". Labels are rarely helpful to the people being labeled.
Quote:

Originally Posted by waterproofmascara
ITA MamaWhit. I prefer to say I escaped a broken home. My home now is full of love; how can that be classified as broken??
ITA, we are much happier (and cleaner) now.
My kids' step-monster told one of them that they were from a broken home, and he responded by saying..."It's not broken; we downsized."
(Out of the mouths of babes, eh?)
See less See more
I agree.. I think the only people who truly use this term and believe it, are those who are not and have not been in our shoes before
I agree.. I think the only people who truly use this term and believe it, are those who are not and have not been in our shoes before
Unfortunately, Jenn, that's not true. I know of remarried women who look down on divorced women, too. That's why they're so "happy" to be in unhappy marriages, right now! Better married than alone is their motto.

Um, I'll take alone, thanks.
blech!! I agree I'd much rather be all alone than married to my X or someone where I felt like I did being married to him
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top