Mothering Forum banner

I need your help re: stevia and probiotics

2712 Views 29 Replies 10 Participants Last post by  cjr
2
Hey mamas! I did some searching around, but I'm still confused about a couple or few things.


So, is stevia a go or no-go? Is it relatively safe for everyday usage as an alternative to sugar? I keep seeing threads with contradictory info. Is this something I'm just gonna have to sort out and see for myself? I'd rather not, as sugar elim is for my special needs 3 yo.

Next thing-he gets a LOT of yogurt for his gut. Should I be doing probiotics (like powders) in addition or would that be overkill? Also, isn't there a certain probiotic I should be avoiding due to yeasties? This is where I start getting confused.

Ok-bonus last q's.
About the kefir...I thought that would be a nice, natural alternative to probiotic powders, but I don't even know where to get it let alone what to do with it once I find it. Should I skip the powder stuff and do kefir instead? Again, should I do it in combo with yogurt or will it suffice on its own? I could actually make my own yogurts with it, couldn't I? Is that the deal-I mix it in with say, coconut milk for a highly fermented thick drink, right?

I'm sorry for all the questions. Just imagine how many I'd be asking if I hadn't even read some previous threads! eeeek.
See less See more
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
Personally, I love stevia. I don't use a lot, it's natural, and the Indigenous folks of South America have been using it for eons with no trouble. Donna Gates, who wrote the Body Ecology Diet, and someone I really respect wrt nutrition, is a big advocate of stevia. I think any kind of sweetener has it's downfall, but stevia, for me, is a better choice than white sugar and *shudder* artificial sweeteners like Equal, Sweet & Low and Splenda.

I would try to get all the probiotics in with whole foods. You can culture just about anything. I am not super familiar with kefir, but IIRC it can be used anywhere you'd use yogurt or even milk because of it's thin consistency. Also if you culture your own kefir it will have stronger probiotics.

Best of luck! sg
I was just about to ask some questions about stevia, so I'll piggyback, phishmama, if you don't mind!


Selu Gigage (or anyone), what kind do you use? I've used it before but didn't care for the taste in certain things (coffee comes to mind), and have heard differing reports about which kind tastes better/isn't bitter/etc. Liquid, powder? Any particular brands you can recommend?

TIA!
~Nick
See less See more
Very interesting reading! So I just rolled thru a bunch of info, started on BED, then hit stevia-plant.com, and some others with basic urls like that, and some UofOregon studies and info. Overall, it looked too good to be true. And with so many cross indications! I even turned my search around, trying to find risks and warnings and all I found was one statement regarding possible kidney problems (but I don't recall if it actually referenced a study, b/c I didn't see that study), and two rat studies that showed reproductive problems. Has anyone seen anything worse? I am not a good web searchy type person. Well, so far, I'm in favor of trying out this "food additive" (priceless that the FDA has that much control, eh?). Your thoughts?

Hey Nick-it looks like the diff btwn powdered ground leaves vs. liquid is the strength of it. Check out the stevia-plant.com web site b/c they had a conversion table for how much powder or liquid needed vs. regular white sugar. I obviously have no clue about the taste.
See less See more
Nick, I use the Sweetleaf Stevia Plus in packets. I use about 1 packet per large cup of coffee, tea or smoothie.
Oh packets, bless your heart. That will make it easy for me...I'm waaay too groggy in the mornings to be bothered with spoons...!

Phishmama, thanks for the links! Off to check 'em out. I'm headed to the NFS later and now I'll go informed.

~n
I use stevia almost everyday in kefir, not even a 1/8 teaspoon. I personally am satisfied with the large amount of reading I have done on it... plus it has been used traditionally for a great number of years. I have seen the study re: reproductive problems, but I think they were eating their weight in stevia. I think any substance would do damage at that rate.

Now, FOS however, that is in Stevia Plus, I'm not so sure about. I've seen several warnings on it lately (more in link below)

Re: Probiotics
Let me tell you, I have spent hundreds of dollars on powdered probiotics in the past couple years... and they helped for sure. But homemade kefir kicks their butt. You get trillions of live probiotics in just a small amount of kefir, compared to just billions in dried form in the capsules which may or not be totally active. Plus the probiotics in your own kefir are freshly born and in their natural growth medium, so they are thought to colonize the gut more effectively.

Yogurt and kefir more effective than probiotic pills (also see FOS warning):
http://www.healingcrow.com/ferfun/co...onspiracy.html

I love the Body Ecology powder kefir starter:
https://www9.mailordercentral.com/bo...item=1&mitem=2

It's very easy to culture, you add warm milk and let sit on counter for 18 to 24 hrs. It reproduces exactly the same taste every time. You can make a lot from just one packet if you divide it the right way. (There are 6 packets in a box.)

One packet makes 1 qt. of kefir, which then you can use a little finished kefir as a starter make up to a gallon at a time. You can divide it up to 7 times. However, I figured out if you take the first quart and make multiple batches, then those batches can go 7 times, etc. etc. I have been putting some in the frig. to culture very slowly (cold slows growth) and some on the counter to culture first.

I have some awesome live grains now though. They took a couple of days to recover from their journey and now they are reproducing like mad. The grains can last forever with proper care. They also culture in about 24 hrs at room temperature but they do take a little more work. Just a little though... I usually buzz my finished kefir with a stick blender to make it creamy and then let it mature for another few hours to a day to get nice and tart. Some people think the grains are yucky... they are like little beads of tapioca stuck together, I used to think that too but now they are my friends :LOL

I'm eating the grains too, which is another huge benefit...a neverending supply of probiotic pills! So I'll save the powder starter for vacation or in an emergency.

Let me know if you have any questions but I'm seriously worshipping kefir right now, it's amazing. I've spent a long time trying to heal our guts for good and I think this is indeed the answer.
See less See more
I agree on the kefir being the best thing a person can get for the good flora in the intestines. I drink a kefir smoothie every morning with stevia and fruit and protein powder and it makes me feel SO good! I have only recently started making my own kefir with grains a friend gave me and it's awesome.

If you just want to try kefir and aren't ready to make your own though it can be gotten at places like Whole Foods or any natural foods market in the dairy section, same place as the milk. My favourite brand is Helios but Lifeway makes and organic kind now as well.

And it's WAY better than yogurt for probiotics.
Has anyone had any problems with yeast since they started drinking kefir? I started drinking it in December and immediately began having problems with Candida. It was a serious problem for me for months. Then, I gave up dairy and stopped drinking the kefir. Since I stopped I have not had one yeast reacurrance. Another friend of mine, who is very intuned with her body, noticed the same thing. Actually she brought it to my attention when we were discussing my yeast problems and the fact that I have not had any issues with it in a few months. She linked the two and said she did research on it and found that one of the yeasts in kefir is Candida causing. Which we both find odd since it's supposed to be a cure for Candida. I'm afraid to start drinking it again. Seriously, I have never had such a yeast issue than when I was drinking kefir. These were the live kefir grains.

I bought some stevia plants. The market had them so I figured I may as well get it straight from the source. Just wondering if I need to dry them first or can I steep the leaves with my tea or coffee? The leaf is very sweet to chew on, but it doesn't have that after taste that the powdered stuff has.
See less See more
Oh thats great that you found some stevia CJR. All you need to do is toss a a pinch of the herb in with a loose tea mix and steep along side the other herbs.

You can make a strong tea out of the herb and use that concentrated strong tea to sweeten baking too!
Thanks
I'm pretty excited about it. I bought a bunch of herbs to grow, but never got around to planting them. So, I'm buying them. I figure if I start my seeds now or even in a month from now, when these plants die then I will have new ones ready to go.

I love teas but I need just a little sweetener in them. Not even very much, but some so I was thrilled to find the stevia plant. I can't stand the powdered stuff.
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by cjr
Has anyone had any problems with yeast since they started drinking kefir? I started drinking it in December and immediately began having problems with Candida. It was a serious problem for me for months. Then, I gave up dairy and stopped drinking the kefir. Since I stopped I have not had one yeast reacurrance. Another friend of mine, who is very intuned with her body, noticed the same thing. Actually she brought it to my attention when we were discussing my yeast problems and the fact that I have not had any issues with it in a few months. She linked the two and said she did research on it and found that one of the yeasts in kefir is Candida causing. Which we both find odd since it's supposed to be a cure for Candida. I'm afraid to start drinking it again. Seriously, I have never had such a yeast issue than when I was drinking kefir. These were the live kefir grains.
That is really weird.. as far as "issues" you noticed, could it be from canidida die off? Donna Gates of The Body Ecology Diet is one of the few authorities on candida and healing the gut and kefir is central to her program.

I'd like to see this research as it counters everything I have read so far and I certainly don't want to be making our situation come back if this is true. Can you ask your friend?
See less See more
This is what happened with me. In December I recieved my kefir grains and a week later (after consuming for a week) I began mestrating. As soon as I began mestrating I had a terrible case of candida. I alway got candida during my pg's, but not usually any other time. I kept drinking the kefir until the end of March and into April. Every cycle I would get the same thing, bad candida. Then I started implimented Eat to Live which meant cutting out all dairy. Once I stopped the kefir no more yeast. As a matter of fact all my menstral problems stopped. During those months on kefir I had terrible menstral cramps, pms, headache, the works. My cycle has just ended and it was the best cycle ever. No candida, no crampy, no headache and no pms. I mentioned this to my friend and she made a comment about the kefir causing the candida. She said she started having problems with candida when after she started consuming kefir. She stopped and so did the problems. She looked up the bacteria and yeast in kefir and said one of the yeasts was a yeast found it candida. This is what I got from our converstation. She will need to elaberate more if she feels like going into it.

All I know is that I'm afraid to start up with the kefir again. It was nasty.
See less See more
Wow, thanks everyone for contributing to this thread! Jane, I'm gonna have to print this thread, lol.

So, Jane, the FOS is the inulin, right? Yeah, that is what I was worried about remembering to try to avoid if I went the powdered route.

I actually did have another question-do I introduce this gradually to avoid gi distress? I'm assuming we may initially be possibly gassy or bloated or crampy? Will we?

Mountainmom-if you peek back in here-thanks for the steeping tip (to cjr). That is a great idea!
2
I am the friend


I went on Dom's site and found the bacteria content of typical live kefir grains. One of the bacterias was candida. So candida also exsists on kefir grains. I found that when I started kefir, for the first time in my life, I battled candida based issues. I counsel clients on candida and have a whole healing program for candida in my practice so I know alot about candida, die off etc. I have never had a yeast infection in my life. But when I started kefir, I noticed the ph of my yoni changed. Sorry for TMI. I also noticed fuzzy headed syndrome and itchy ears and skin. I stopped the kefir and within two weeks was back to normal.

I went on a candida cleanse for 6 weeks anyway to be sure.



Not a scientific approach but a life experience. Not everyone is the same mind you. Perhaps my GI tract was not able to process the kefir effectively. I have my own homemade youghurt often and all kinds of ferments with no candida symptoms or issues.

Go figure.
See less See more
Mountain Mom, do you think we would get the same reaction from a starter package from Body Ecology? I know it's not as good as live kefir grains, but if you look on the list of bacteria, do you see the ingredient that could be causing the candida problems? I would use a starter if it meant keeping candida at bay.
I am not sure CJR.

Candida is a strain of bacteria so I can't imagine that the packaged one has it exsisting since that is regulated.

Any ferment has some level of Candida to it. Candida exsists in our GI tract. Its when the balance is off that you end up with an issue. Perhaps my live grains had more content of candida than others. I am not sure.

I don't know what to suggest. My personal experience goes against the grain, so it may be an isolated incident. More than likely it is.

I say try some kefir and see how your body reacts. All you can do is try. I would suggest the live over the packaged though because of quality.
I bought Carter some goat milk so maybe I will try fermenting it with the kefir grains and see what happens.
See less See more
4
Quote:

Originally Posted by mountain mom
I am the friend


I went on Dom's site and found the bacteria content of typical live kefir grains. One of the bacterias was candida. So candida also exsists on kefir grains. I found that when I started kefir, for the first time in my life, I battled candida based issues. I counsel clients on candida and have a whole healing program for candida in my practice so I know alot about candida, die off etc. I have never had a yeast infection in my life. But when I started kefir, I noticed the ph of my yoni changed. Sorry for TMI. I also noticed fuzzy headed syndrome and itchy ears and skin. I stopped the kefir and within two weeks was back to normal.

I went on a candida cleanse for 6 weeks anyway to be sure.



Not a scientific approach but a life experience. Not everyone is the same mind you. Perhaps my GI tract was not able to process the kefir effectively. I have my own homemade youghurt often and all kinds of ferments with no candida symptoms or issues.

Go figure.
Well...
That is really strange. I'm definately NOT discounting your experience at all, just trying to make sense of it.

Candida albicans is not part of live grain kefir...

Yeasts (from Dom's site)
Saccharomyces cerevisiae
S. florentinus
S. pretoriensis
Candida valida
C. lambica
Kloeckera apiculata
Hansenula yalbensis

This is a mystery!

Body Ecology Kefir starter

Ingredients (from Mercola.com):
Kefir Culture Starter
Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis
Lactococcus lactis subsp. cremoris
Lactococcus lactis subsp. diacetylactis
Leuconostoc mesenteroides subsp. cremoris
Lactobacillus kefyr
Klyveromyces marxianus var. marxianus
Saccaromyces unisporus
Carrier: dextrose, waterfree

Quote:
mercola.com Introducing Kefir into Your Diet: Some people thrive on kefir right from the start and others may need to proceed more slowly. For those who have candidiasis, I recommend a slower build up for tolerance. Start with about four ounces in the morning on an empty stomach. Every second day, increase the amount until you are able to drink a full eight ounce glass.

Quote:
mercola.com Additionally, Kefir contains several major strains of friendly bacteria not commonly found in yogurt: Lactobacillus Caucasus, Leuconostoc, Acetobacter species, and Streptococcus species. It also contains beneficial yeasts, such as Saccharomyces kefir and Torula kefir, which dominate, control and eliminate destructive pathogenic yeasts in the body by penetrating the mucosal lining where unhealthy yeast and bacteria reside -- forming a virtual SWAT team that housecleans and strengthens the intestines. Consequently, the body becomes more efficient in resisting pathogens like E. coli and intestinal parasites.
Or maybe age has something to do with it :LOL
Kefir Milk Enhances Intestinal Immunity in Young but Not Old Rats
http://www.nutrition.org/cgi/content/full/131/3/807

I also want to say that the interesting thing I noted is that when I first got my grains in the mail, they were very yeasty smelling and tasting. Totally turned me off. And the kefir was yeasty for several days afterwards. My understanding it that the composition of the bacteria/yeasts strive for balance if they are fed correctly, at correct temperature for culture, etc. But if they dont' have enough food or are kept at a higher temperature, the yeasts will grow more quickly as a self preservation method. Actually, this turned me off of kefir grains when I first tried them 6 months ago. Then I got the Body Ecology powder and loved it, b/c it was consistent from day 1. But then I started reading more about the grains.

All I can say is that I am very, very sensitive to yeasts and carbs. My IBS symptoms returned whenever I strayed. OR shall I say, was very sensitive. Until I started drinking kefir. I noticed a huge improvement right away from the Body Ecology version, so I know that one is effective, even if it isn't "real" according to kefir die hards
See less See more
Good information Jane!

I think I more than likely read that list saw Candida and assumed it was albican.

I also converted my milk grains to juice grains, so perhaps there is an angle there.

Like I said, I would think its an isolated incident, not representative of Kefir consumption in general.

In the program I have for clients, for the first two weeks to a month, depending of candida levels, all ferments are avoided as are grains, root veg and obvious flour and sugar sources. Perhaps I actually needed a cleanse and since introducing all the ferments the kefir tipped me over the edge.

I no doubt will try it again. I froze my water grains. I always felt good with those.
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top