Mothering Forum banner

Is alright to have a pacifer in between the feedings

638 Views 14 Replies 14 Participants Last post by  VBurd
Or else your baby would be on the breast all day and so on.

Thank you.
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
NAK
we started dd w one at 10 days or so cause she was always sucking on our fingers and we figured when we were away from home a binkie was cleaner
I let both of my babes try it in the early months for those times when they really needed to suck, although we also used fingers. Neither of mine wanted it after a few tries. Remember that by 3 months give or take they can find their own fingers/thumb. The sucking need is also not quite so intense by that phase. If a babe develops a preference for pacie over breast or own fingers that can be an issue!
Babies suck for a reason, mainly to help establish milk supply, but also for comfort. I would hesitate to offer a pacifier to a very young baby because of a possibility of nipple confusion and messing with baby's latch. The need to suck around the clock does lessen as baby gets older. Remember, the breast is the original pacifier!
I would not start a pacifier before 6 weeks and even then IMO it should be avoided. Babies are designed to need to suck. That need to suck is designed to create an adequate milk supply. You don't want to short circuit the design.

Personally we don't use pacifiers.

-Angela
Quote:

Originally Posted by alegna
I would not start a pacifier before 6 weeks and even then IMO it should be avoided. Babies are designed to need to suck. That need to suck is designed to create an adequate milk supply. You don't want to short circuit the design.

Personally we don't use pacifiers.

-Angela


and agreeing also on sheri's explanation.

there was one stuck in ds's mouth when he was in the newborn nursery.

i think that was one of the contributing factors to our difficulties establishing our nursing relationship.
See less See more
I agree it depends on age. I would at least wait 6 weeks or so until everything is going well. Even then I would be hesitant there is nothing wrong with comfort nursing. That being said if you need a break for your sanity you can try it. Just make sure you don't fall back on it to often and try to hold off on nursing because then it could become an issue.
The recommendation is to wait until at least 6 weeks - otherwise pacifiers can be a contributing factor to nipple confusion and/or bfing problems in general.

Why would it be a bad thing for the baby to be on the breast all day? That's exactly where newborns should be IMO and if it's a problem or the mom really needs to get something done, she could pop the baby in a sling and off she goes.

My DS spent DAYS and DAYS at my breast - it was just what he did. The housework didn't get done and dinner barely got cooked, but man, did we have one happy contented baby on our hands.

And babies especially need those times of sucking during a growth spurt - they *need* to ramp up the milk supply, so they're sucking for a reason.
2
we have no pacifier here
She does nurse a lot, but not all day
See less See more
2
dd was a natural born sucker! we gave her a pac earlier than recommended, at about a week old, but we knew this kid had no problems with her latch. She did fine, and now at 4 mo, has weened off of it herself, onto her thumb


She would suck on a breast or our finger all day if she could, but a mama's gotta cook some dinner, ya know
See less See more
Quote:
Why would it be a bad thing for the baby to be on the breast all day?
Because for a brand new nursing mother, that can sometimes lead to bleeding, cracked nipples. That is what happened in my case. My newborn wanted to nurse quite literally 24 hours a day. And the pain was just insane, after a week or two of this marathon nursing. I had worked with a lactation consultant, both in the hospital and at home, so I knew it wasn't a problem with the latch. It was just the frequency of her nursing. So we introduced a pacifier between feedings, to meet her sucking needs, and to give my poor, bleeding nipples a rest. She used it for just over a year (I don't think she "needed" it that long, though), and quit without a problem.

With my second baby, my nipples were already conditioned to dealing with baby-abuse, so I didn't have the same problem, even through the comfort nursing. We didn't bother with a pacifier. And he never did find his thumb.
See less See more
I can't say what is best, but I can tell my my experience with both of my children.

DD #1 was born 4 weeks early and was VERY sleepy and I had a hard time nursing at first - she wouldn't latch on and when she did it was very painful. It was so difficult, but it finally worked a few weeks in. She nursed beautifully and all was well except sometimes she was very fussy and refused the breast. We offered a pacifier at about 3 weeks and she took it. Just to let everyone know, I was VERY determined to breastfeed and was not sure about this step, but I was exhausted and desperate. Anyway, Carmella nursed exlusively (no formula) and took a pacifier, and when she was about 5 months old, she didn't want/need the pacifier anymore. She self-weaned at 2 years old.

DS had a hard time latching on at first too, but since I was more experienced, I was more relaxed and our nursing relationship was much easier in the beginning. We also offered him a pacifier at a few weeks old, and he took it. He also nursed exclusively(no formula), and started to refuse the pacifier around 5 months old.

I felt that babies have a real need to suck (almost constantly in our case) and I wasn't able to provide this all the time (sore nipples being one reason.) I really felt that in offering the pacifier I was able to keep my baby content and myself in good operating condition for nursing. It worked for us, thank goodness.

for me, I always kept in mind that nursing is a relationship between 2 people, and like any relationship, it has to work and be healthy for both people involved. This is what worked for us
See less See more
Thank you for your wonderful responses to this and resurrances on that you shouldn't give your baby pacifer if you bf.
I think it depends on the baby and age. Some are really affected by having a pacifier and the moms don't make enough milk.

Not all children and moms are the same so don't make such a blanket statement.
I offered my daughter a pacifier at three weeks old. I did so because I *knew* she had the latch down just fine. She was a champion nurser from the start. Once I felt confident that my supply was well-established and that she knew what she was doing, I felt okay giving her the paci. I felt a little bashful about it at first but, frankly, my nipples were about to jump off of my body and run away.

Also, my daughter made it very clear when she actually need the breast and when she just wanted to suck. If she was actually hungry and I tried to give her a paci she let me know immediately that that was not was she was looking for. She gave the paci up at about three months old in favor of her thumb. She is now six months old and she is a serious thumb sucker.

Anyway, I think you have to do what feels comfortable. If you're concerned about latch or supply, I would wait. But otherwise, I think it's okay to use one if it's not at the expense of other needs.
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top