Mothering Forum banner

My mother made me ask this question

1167 Views 27 Replies 15 Participants Last post by  mezzaluna
Her one objection to the concept of EC is that she prefers changing diapers to cleaning out potties. So that made me wonder, what do you usually do to clean out your potty/bucket/bowl if you use one?
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
I don't do EC w my 8 mo old - well I do put dd on the potty when she poos tho - but that's it. but i think baby potties are completely useless. Just hold them over a real potty. At 8 months dd sits nicely on it with me supporting her so she doesn't fall in. My mom never used potties for us for the most part - tho we didn't use the toilet til toddler age. I had DD on the potty at 3 mo one time for a poo tho too so I think it works.
I heard a good idea from an experienced ECing family recently - they drape a prefold on top of the little potty before putting their DS on it. Then, any pee/poop goes into the diaper instead of the potty. Plus, if the potty is cold, that isn't an issue at all. This would definitely be something to consider if you'd rather wash dipes than potties. OTOH, you still have to wash something. Putting the baby on a toilet gets rid of this problem altogether. Guess it depends what works for you and your DC!
Oh I'm hoping to have a baby who doesn't mind the toilet. This was more curiousity since a lot of people seem to mostly use a vessel of some kind. I figure if people are taking little potties everywhere and using them in airplanes and things the washing process isn't that bad, I just was wondering what it was.

The prefold in the potty idea doesn't really appeal since that still requires washing a diaper and one of the appeals of EC for me is using/washing fewer diapers. Right now, years in advance of need, I'm leaning towards lining a potty with a plastic bag when traveling.
I use the big people potty. just flush!!!

I am like your mom though I would rather change a diaper then clean out a bowl. I cant even imagine useing my bowls for that, even gladwear or something......

btw, my daughter is 2 months. At first (2 weeks) I would just pee her over her diaper. Then I finally just let her go in the toilet. ever so much easier. She has been useing the toilet since 4 or 5 weeks I think.... She doesnt sit on it like a big girl because, well she cant sit up yet. I lean over the toilet and I hold her mostly on my left arm with her head in the crook of my elbow my left hand holds back her left leg and my right hand holds back her right leg.
I have tried various methods. I started out just peeing on an open pre-fold. Then, put the baby over an actual toilet. As she got older, I preferred the Baby Bjorn, b/c I could take it everywhere (I don't like public restrooms and I certainly wasn't putting my baby over one of those toilets!) and it's so easy to clean. I just poured everything in the toilet (poops is really liquidy for many months since baby is breastfed) and then rinsed the potty out. Every now and then, I washed it with soap and water.

I found the potty cleaning much more palatable than I thought I would. I don't like cleaning potties, either, but cleaning the potty after a 6mo and cleaning it after a 3yo are two, very different things.
Though it is nice to not have to clean out a little potty and just have them go in the big people potty, I found that I was more comfortable and patient if I could sit behind my DS as he sat on the baby bjorn potty. It helped me be able to wait for him to take a poop, and really finish it and not rush him b/c my back was hurting.

However, you could suggest to your mother that peeing/pooping outside would be the best of all worlds. Nothing to clean up, just a little toilet paper to wipe. Depends on your neighborhood and outdoor environment, but our DS loved peeing outside (before our current potty strike). He loved to watch it just fly, and wasn't able to do that on the potty.
I think I have a baby bjorn potty seat that goes over the big potty. I think it is adjustable too (haven't had it out yet). That might be good for a baby that doesn't like to dangle. I hold my dd's legs and sit backward on the potty with her. I think she likes to have me behind her. And, she has done this in public restrooms too. Although I have to be really careful that she doesn't touch anything (public restrooms really gross me out - but even worse, the changing tables!). I did buy a little potty when she was peeing on the changing table before I decided to EC full time, I got one of those on the go pottys (they sell them at the EC store) and now it just stays in the car, oh and I use a prefold under it.
2
I was thinking my mom wasn't phased by anything and now I find out that she's all kinds of wimpy.
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by sapphire_chan
Her one objection to the concept of EC is that she prefers changing diapers to cleaning out potties.
Wondr if she'll change her tune once she sees how much easier it is to clean the baby's bottom with EC!
See less See more
We live on a boat and we can't flush human waste (goes right into our marina!) so for that reason we prefer the BBLP. (Actually, I have trouble holding DS over a big toilet for as long as it sometimes takes him to go, and he prefers not to be dangling.) So we use our BBLP with an 8-12 cup basket-style coffee filter in it, then sprinkle a little Pooh Powder on it. This gels up the pee and makes the poop safe to throw into the trash, and the filter makes it super easy to remove it from the potty without making a mess. After that we have a spray bottle of very dilute bleach plus simple green that we use with a small paper towel if the potty needs more cleaning. It sounds complicated, looking at it all written out like this, but it really is easy, and it encourages me to potty DS when we're out, as I carry an extra BBLP and supplies in the car, so I can set up a little "bathroom" in the wayback of our station wagon.
We have always used the bathroom sink. When poos were runny, I'd just run the water and let it all run down the drain. Now that DS is on solids and poops are usually pretty solid, I just pick it up with a piece of TP and flush it down the toilet. Then there are the in-between poops, and those are pretty yukky!

Even with the mess, though I prefer the sink to the toilet because it's much easier on my back to hold him standing up rather than me bending over or squatting to hold him over the toilet. We haven't quite gotten the hang of having him sit on the toilet, and he's not fond of the BBLP.

DS's new favorite (and sometimes only lately) potty is the bathtub. I think he likes the sound it makes when he pees
(big metal tub + big echoy bathroom = cool sound LOL)
See less See more
4
Quote:

Originally Posted by lizajane30
Wondr if she'll change her tune once she sees how much easier it is to clean the baby's bottom with EC!

My mother is fabulous in many ways, but I have a feeling I'll need to be in practice before I try demostrating EC to her. But hey, as long as she changes diapers quickly and is willing to help me do laundry I've got no problems if she doesn't want to try it.


And who knows, maybe in the next couple of years she'll read an article on ECing that totally changes her mind, right? My dh is already on board and we aren't even planning to TTC for another year and a half.
See less See more
4
Quote:

Originally Posted by tsfairy
Even with the mess, though I prefer the sink to the toilet because it's much easier on my back to hold him standing up rather than me bending over or squatting to hold him over the toilet. We haven't quite gotten the hang of having him sit on the toilet, and he's not fond of the BBLP.
On diaperfreebaby.org one of the positions shows the mom holding the baby on the toilet while she sits on a stool. I wonder if you could do something like that while still holding him up. Maybe a chair to raise you higher? Just kind of sitting here at my computer mentally picturing holding a baby
I think you could probably arrange things so you could brace your arms on your legs. But then again, who has room for a chair in their bathroom?
"what's this folding chair doing in here?" "oh, that's my chair for when I potty the baby." "
??" "
"
See less See more
I don't think pouring pee out of a potty is a big deal. It's WAY less trouble than getting to a toilet every time a baby needs to pee or poop. You can keep a potty right near you, and empty it whenever you need to get up anyway.

My daughter is almost two and a half and we haven't had accidents in months. We still use our little potties all the time. She is much more agreeable to pottying if I can bring it to her rather than interrupt whatever she is doing.

I just started putting a square or two of toilet paper in the bottom of the potty. Makes it so much easier to clean poo out of.

I wouldn't put a diaper over the potty if I didn't have to. Not having to wash diapers is a great advantage of EC.
I love all the ideas people are sharing. I also think it's really cool that everyone has a different style.
3
We only use the little potty at night (so we just hold her over the side of the pallet and don't have to go to the bathroom) or if we're in the middle of something. She almost never poops in the potty. Usually it's in the sink when she poops and she's exclusively bf so her poops just rinse right down the drain (hey, they all end up in the same place!
). When we dump her little potty we just dump it in the bathtub (unless she pooped in it, which almost never happens - then we dump in the toilet and then rinse in the tub), rinse it out, and we put a bit of vinegar in the bottom of the potty in case she poops in it before peeing in it (so it doesn't stick). We only empty it out once a day or after a poop. She only poops every few days anyhow
When dd was a newborn we just had her go on prefolds (with her laying on the prefold) and gave her the cuing noise as she went. When she would poop I would keep ahead of her by moving the prefold to clean spots while she was pooping. It helped that step-MIL gave us diaper service for 3 months...

SO much easier to wipe after an EC'd poop!!!

love and peace.
See less See more
Quote:

Originally Posted by emiLy
I don't think pouring pee out of a potty is a big deal. It's WAY less trouble than getting to a toilet every time a baby needs to pee or poop. You can keep a potty right near you, and empty it whenever you need to get up anyway.
I wash my hands after ecing so either way I am going to have to get up and go to the bathroom.

Quote:

Originally Posted by emiLy
My daughter is almost two and a half and we haven't had accidents in months. We still use our little potties all the time. She is much more agreeable to pottying if I can bring it to her rather than interrupt whatever she is doing.
....
I actually remember when I was little the thing I had the worst problem with was stopping what I was doing to go to the bathroom. I always waited until the last minute. It was always a mad dash in those days. I have already started to notice that my 2 month old will hold it until we get up to the potty. Of course she doesnt have anything better to do quite yet. Once she figures out how to use her hands and feet it might all change.....

whats all this about dangeling? my daughter is just as supported when I hold her over the potty as she is on the way there. her head is in the crook of my left elbow, part of her back along my left arm. my left hand holds back her left leg. my right thumb holds back her right leg, while the rest of my right hand supports the rest of her back. Sometimes I put the back of her butt against the toilet seat hopeing that the coolness of it might help trigger her (I have started to notice that that is one of my cues). shes really quite secure this way. I can even take away my right hand when shes done and use it to wipe her. I will admit that I am leaning over while I do this, and it prolly will hurt my back when she weighs more, but for now its ok. Maybe sitting on the edge of the tub would work?

The biggest problem I have with waiting for her is if I really have to go. The other day she didnt go right away so I figured I would go and then give her another chance. Well there she was naked and she heard me go so she went.... all over the bathroom, good thing shes a girl I guess or it coulda been worse.
See less See more
We use a BBLP and I hardly ever have to actually clean it. She goes in it, we dump it into the big potty and then rinse and pour the rinse water into the big potty. Her poop is still runny BF poop, so I don't know if that will change, but right now, as long as it's rinsed right away it's usually fine. I just try to clean it every few days, mostly just by swishing a squirt of hand soap around with some water and then rinsing.
2
Quote:

Originally Posted by tash11
The biggest problem I have with waiting for her is if I really have to go. The other day she didnt go right away so I figured I would go and then give her another chance. Well there she was naked and she heard me go so she went.... all over the bathroom, good thing shes a girl I guess or it coulda been worse.

You should try to figure out if there's room for both of you.
See less See more
1 - 20 of 28 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top