Mothering Forum banner
1 - 17 of 17 Posts

· Premium Member
Joined
·
6,218 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/medi...p?newsid=74521

Quote:
The study has a number of important findings that should impact policy decisions in the future. First, male circumcision, which in previous studies had been found to be important in controlling AIDS, becomes statistically irrelevant once the study controls for the number of prostitutes in a country. The study finds that the more Muslim countries of North Africa do indeed suffer much less AIDS than southern and western Africa, but this lower prevalence is not due to higher numbers of circumscribed males in these Muslim communities, but rather results from the fact that there are significantly fewer prostitutes in northern Africa on a per capita basis. It appears that religious families in the north, specifically concerned fathers and brothers, do a much better job protecting their daughters from predatory males than do those in the south. A history of polygamy in these Muslim communities does not appear to contribute to higher AIDS prevalence as previously speculated. In a frequently cited academic paper, Daniel Halperin, an H.I.V. specialist at the Harvard Center for Population and Development and one of the world's leading advocates for male circumcision, weighted results from individual countries by their population. When this artificial weighting was removed Talbott found that circumcision was no longer statistically significant in explaining the variance in AIDS infection rates across the countries of the World.

Quote:
Second, to date, there has not been an adequate explanation as to why Africa as a continent is experiencing an AIDS epidemic far in excess of any other region of the world with some African countries' prevalence rates exceeding 25% of the adult population and tens of millions dying from the disease on the continent. Talbott's new study suggests that the reason is that Africa as a whole has four times as many prostitutes as the rest of the word and they are more than four times as infected. Some southern Africa countries have as many as 7% of their adult females infected and working as prostitutes while in the developed world typically this percentage of infected prostitutes is less than .1%. If these 7% of infected prostitutes in Africa sleep with five men in a week that means they are subjecting 35% of the country's male population to the virus weekly. The virus is not easy to transmit heterosexually, but over time with multiple exposures, infection is inevitable. These men then act as a conduit to bring the virus home to their villages, their other casual sex partners and to their wives.

The study has important policy implications. Several international AIDS organizations have begun to provide funding for male circumcisions as a deterrent to AIDS. While male circumcision may indeed reduce the risk of transmission by some 50% to 60% in each sexual encounter, reducing single encounter transmission rates alone cannot control the epidemic. The reason is that individuals in highly infected countries have multiple contacts with the infected so reducing transmission rates only defers the inevitable.
Spread it around!!!!!
 

· Registered
Joined
·
619 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by carriebft View Post
While male circumcision may indeed reduce the risk of transmission by some 50% to 60% in each sexual encounter, reducing single encounter transmission rates alone cannot control the epidemic. The reason is that individuals in highly infected countries have multiple contacts with the infected so reducing transmission rates only defers the inevitable.

I'm glad somebody else pointed this out. Even if its slows the transmission rate, it is not a "cure." The circ'd men were still getting HIV; it's just a matter of delaying it.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
8,855 Posts
You know, we're read about the prostitute issue before. The sad thing, politics "gets in the way" of effective treatment. Government organizations often will do what others view as politically and morally "safe" rather than doing what works.

Hense the lack of funding for condom use, and ignoring the impact of prostitutes....sad huh?
:

I do hope that this makes SOME people think about this connection. Pretty obvious, glad someone wrote it up doing the research, addressing it statistically. I hope THIS gets some good press.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
11,048 Posts
And this is why circumcision is going to fail miserably as a prevention tool against HIV....men will get cut and then go back to sleeping with prostitutes and/or multiple partners. Eventually they'll get infected, and then pass it on.

The only part of the article I didn't like was the quasi-editorializing about how much better North African fathers and brothers are at "protecting" women from becoming prostitutes. I think that the roots of prostitution are far, far more complicated than whether women have male family members to "protect" them.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
6,218 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
Quirky, I was hesitant to post it for that reason as well. I found the article on a few other sites but so far they all have that paragraph in them with the word "protecting."
 

· Registered
Joined
·
219 Posts
Quote:
Second, to date, there has not been an adequate explanation as to why Africa as a continent is experiencing an AIDS epidemic far in excess of any other region of the world with some African countries' prevalence rates exceeding 25% of the adult population and tens of millions dying from the disease on the continent.
One issue - in some parts of the continent there's a myth that raping a virgin will cure you of the disease! I'm not kidding you! My aunt worked somewhere in Africa (forget where, this was 15 years ago) as a missionary and heard this first-hand, needless to say she was utterly horrified.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,161 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien View Post
One issue - in some parts of the continent there's a myth that raping a virgin will cure you of the disease! I'm not kidding you! My aunt worked somewhere in Africa (forget where, this was 15 years ago) as a missionary and heard this first-hand, needless to say she was utterly horrified.

Hi. Can you get me details on this, please? Anything would help. Thanks.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
1,860 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien View Post
One issue - in some parts of the continent there's a myth that raping a virgin will cure you of the disease! I'm not kidding you! My aunt worked somewhere in Africa (forget where, this was 15 years ago) as a missionary and heard this first-hand, needless to say she was utterly horrified.

I have a friend from South Africa who told me about this myth


Apparently "the younger the better", too
:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,158 Posts
Britain's Prince Harry has actually co-founded a charity in Lesotho to help with the AIDS epidemic there (among other issues). I saw a documentary about it a year or so back in which he was visiting a baby who had been raped due to the belief that it was a cure for AIDS. The charity's website discusses this.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,161 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by velcromom View Post
Thanks for posting this, I am sharing it with my husband.. I found out today that he thinks the research supporting circumcision to prevent HIV was "compelling".
Compelling him to circ because... HIV scares him?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3,655 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien View Post
One issue - in some parts of the continent there's a myth that raping a virgin will cure you of the disease! I'm not kidding you! My aunt worked somewhere in Africa (forget where, this was 15 years ago) as a missionary and heard this first-hand, needless to say she was utterly horrified.

I have heard this myth in the US too.
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top