What about going to the second-hand store and finding some new or like new toys? I just went to one over the weekend and bought a (like new) wooden car, a (brand new) wooden ring stacking toy, a (like new) xylophone, and brand new limited edition Amy Coe Rabbit-in-the-Box, all for $12.00. You can't tell that any of it was used.
Otherwise, here is a neat toy that I found at Target that I like for Andrew:
Thank you for the reccomendations. DD liked the pic of the toy posted. I am afraid if I bought that one she would take it from him. Sometimes I have to buy two of somethig just so that doesn't happen. Oh well.