Mothering Forum banner

Post-Katrina recommendations for pregnant women

754 Views 11 Replies 11 Participants Last post by  ryssann
AAARRRGHHH! I was so excited when I saw this article in the Washington Post, titled "Group Urges Disaster Planning for Pregnant Women, Babies". Something I remember thinking during Katrina was there should have been a full court press to get mamas nursing all those teeny babies. What I would've given to be able to be an LC in NOLA at that time. I was just horrified by the first-hand accounts of mamas reconstituting formula with dirty water or Mountain Dew, kwim? So I was expecting such a plan to at least mention breastfeeding... maybe even communicating that breastfeeding could be an important part of national disaster preparedness... because if you think about it, the more mamas nursing babies, the more babies live and the fewer babies draining the resources of hospitals, funds, formula drops, etc.

But no..... just the importance of having more formula ready to deliver.
:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn...081601516.html

Anyone care to join me in writing a letter to the Post?
See less See more
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
Thanks for pointing this out. I just posted the article to Lactnet. I'm sure people there will write letters.
Perhaps some of them are even familiar with or helping to write those guidelines? Hopefully breastfeeding IS in the guidelines, but just wasn't mentioned in the article.
Janice
: They didn't even mention it? It should have been the point of the article!
See less See more
Hurricane Wilma hit my house three weeks after my DD was born by c-section. I was having problem with breastfeeding due to tongue tie and had been pumping and supplementing with formula for a week due to the (bad) advice of my OB/GYN and Ped (my nipples were very damaged and latch on was excruciatingly painful and my DD wasn't gaining "enough" weight). When the storm hit and the electric went out I had no way to wash the bottles with hot water so I just kept putting her to the breast. DH ended up evacuating us to his mothers house and we got the tongue tie fixed a week or two later (when the electricity was back on). Thank goodness I had been breastfeeding, or we would have had some problems. We are still bfing 9 months later.
WTH?

Formula, vaccines and vitamins? Thats whats important? How about stress the importance of breastfeeding? Sheesh...
All that they needed to include in the "necessary" items for teams would have been "Lactation Consultants," and I'd have agreed with a lot of the article (all? most?) .... Seriously, the rest are all good to have (although I don't see why formula is necessary, at least for the newborns - the breastmilk would be SO MUCH safer for baby than formula in those sorts of situations, so why not just work hard to help mother/infant initiate bf?) -- but for a mother who's ff a 5 month old, the formula will be necessary, relactation is a long row to hoe at that point and baby needs some sustenance sooner than the mom would be able to produce adequate milk.

Ironic that they didn't point out that the International relief agencies discourage formula donations because they don't want the bf moms they're helping, switching to ff during the aftermath of the disaster.
: [obviously I agree with the International Relief agencies, not the plan in the Post]

I DO agree that emphasizing the importance of bf for pregnant women in areas where disasters could be expected (quake zones, tornado zones, hurricane zones, etc.) is a good thing to do. When I watched Katrina clips (the guy with the two week old he was holding up the cameras saying, "We need formula!" etc.) -- I kept yelling at the TV "Well, put the baby to breast - something is better than nothing right now!!!" And hoping that one of the National Guardswomen sent would be a bf mom who could help moms with relactation. Training in relactation would be really important I'd think.

I got into a debate about this on another board shortly after Katrina -- many moms were saying that even though they exclusively bf'd, they thought it would be good to have a "week's supply or more" of RTF formula on hand, and that they kept it on hand (or planned to get it) in case of an emergency and were kind of snide to those of us who didn't think that was necessary. I told them - look, RTF isn't available for my daughter's allergies anyway. So enough safe water for me to drink, and food for me so I can continue to bf, is all I need. Got that covered, and moving on.
It makes me feel a lot safer, knowing that my child's food source is readily available as long as I am readily available ... and I intend to be readily available!
See less See more
3
Quote:

Originally Posted by turtlewomyn
Hurricane Wilma hit my house three weeks after my DD was born by c-section. I was having problem with breastfeeding due to tongue tie and had been pumping and supplementing with formula for a week due to the (bad) advice of my OB/GYN and Ped (my nipples were very damaged and latch on was excruciatingly painful and my DD wasn't gaining "enough" weight). When the storm hit and the electric went out I had no way to wash the bottles with hot water so I just kept putting her to the breast. DH ended up evacuating us to his mothers house and we got the tongue tie fixed a week or two later (when the electricity was back on). Thank goodness I had been breastfeeding, or we would have had some problems. We are still bfing 9 months later.
Tornados wiped out the power in our neighborhood when my daughter was 8 days old. We were having nipple preference problems and I was pumping and bottlefeeding sometimes even though I knew I shouldn't. The 4-night power outage certainly solved this problem.


Seeing that footage of limp babies in their parents' arms right before I gave birth sealed my commitment to breastfeeding, for sure!
See less See more
wrong. just wrong. :ick
When katrina happened and bf'ing was brought up many times (often by me
) as a way to prevent that sort of tragedy (the hungry babies, not the hurricane) people would jump all over me. Ya wanna know why?

Wait for it.....

Because there's no way a woman could maintain a milk supply with that sort of stress on her.
: So formula would be necessary even for bf'ing moms in that situation. I heard this from 2 people IRL and countless people on the internet. Unfreakinbelievable that people actually believe this. Sure SOME women might lose their milk supply from the stress. But I read that lots of women took on other babies and their milk supplies adjusted to feed those babies too.

My sister's ff'd DD was only about a month old when katrina hit and she was so emotional seeing those hungry babies on tv and it really hit home for her. I mentioned that she could always stockpile formula and water if it made her feel better and *I* was glad because I breastfeed and she's one of the people who said bf'ing women's milk would dry up. Then she said her DD would have starved if that had been them. I said, "no, *I* would have fed you baby and NO, my milk probably wouldn't have dried up." Then I explained to her how bf'ing works and our bodies are *designed* to still produce milk, even under tremedous stress and famine.

So maybe these lists are compiled by people who have no clue about bf'ing and assume what everyone else assumes. That bf'ing doesn't work in times of stress.
Not an excuse really, just maybe a possibility why they *conveniently* left bf'ing off the list. Pure ignorance and nothing else. Unless formula companies gave them a kick-back, which is also entirely possible, I guess.
See less See more
3
Quote:
but for a mother who's ff a 5 month old, the formula will be necessary, relactation is a long row to hoe at that point and baby needs some sustenance sooner than the mom would be able to produce adequate milk.
I would like to see pamphlets and educational materials about hand expressing, wet nursing, etc be in preparedness kits.

In a situation where the water isn't safe, EVREYONE would be better off living off the nearest BFing mother's milk.
ITA. But I know that is unlikely to happen given the fear of HIV, hepatitis etc. not to mention, most importantly, lawsuits.
:
See less See more
After the disasters, I remember reading that the mother's milk would not dry up, and that nursing would actually help reduce the stress levels in the mother, thus making bfing better for everyone involved. I couldn't think of a reason to need formula, but then it hit me, what if something happened to me, but not my DD. If I wasn't around anymore, then, she may need formula.
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top