I have a SC sushi print PUL cover, which is also her AIO if you snap in a soaker. I'm not sure how I'd like it as an AIO, I'm sure it would be trim fitting, but I'd have to see the soaker. I use it as a cover and it fits well. Mine is an XL, and with all the elastic, it looks tiny. Like it'd never fit, but it does, on the tightest snaps.