We've tried a few things. Some are good, some are nasty, salty and overpriced. We like the fish personally. Living in a land locked state and having grown up (in MA) eating fish caught that day stinks. But their fish is actually frozen enough that it's not bad by the time we get it like the grocery store ALWAYS is. I see you're from MA though, and I can promise you that the fish would be a huge disappointment to you. Other than that, we love their pies and ice cream.