As far as the program at place in our school, I have to say that I am in favor of some reforms. We have 30 min in the morning class once a week. The children actually only get about 10 min. because the Spanish teacher must rotate 1/3 of the class for each lesson. Children in their 3rd year have an extra 1/2 hour class in the afternoons. It's extremely disruptive to the work cycle and I think very hard on the Spanish teacher. We are discussing ways to help her and have meetings scheduled. I am not sure who decided about the schedule. It's not very effective.
I think if there is truly a desire for a bilingual education, then the two adults in the Casa should speak different languages. Only with this consistency is the child going to develop the ability. Or maybe have a Spanish teacher that comes for a full morning once a week. My daughter has had 2 years of "Spanish" and does know numbers, some colors and basic greetings. Also, a few song. They learn the basics and they like going to Spanish but it's not really learning another language. My daughter is not able to understand people who speak Spanish when we see them like our friend who is from Mexico and is a High School Spanish Teacher. I took 2 years in High School and I can't understand her very well, granted that was quite a few years ago. Anyway, I guess I figure it's not really as worthwhile as it could be, and definitely not worth it to disturb the children. The ability to concentrate is so fragile at first, it needs to be nurtured and protected. With time and trust, it will slowly lengthen as the child depends more and more on his inner impulse to guide him in learning. The 3 hours is chosen in response to scientifically observable and recorded activity cycles.
The Spanish program could be beautifully integrated into the Children's House. There are a few schools that have bilingual guides or their Spanish teachers are taking M training. This would be ideal for the child who is interested in choosing Spanish materials as he could practice at will, and also for the child who is not interested in learning Spanish - who could choose to do another activity that is more interesting to him. We don't do units, but I do think it would be great to have Montessori Spanish language materials included on the shelf like sandpaper letters and moveable alphabet. Is it the same alphabet? Of course, the child would have lots of spoken language and soundgames in Espanol before these.
I feel the same way about all the "specials". It's unfortunate that some schools have to compromise this aspect of the M theory. It's not like we don't include art, music, language and movement, it should be integrated in the environment and not "taught" in the traditional way but experienced in the Montessori way.