I second (third, fourth, whateva!) Enrico's! So yummy... I'm not a big fan of Village Pizza, and haven't eaten at Holland Pizza, so can't give opinions on that.
Definately hit the Shaw's for groceries rather than the S&S. And it's also closer, too
We just tried the Thai Place, and will be going back!
Churchill's Eatery, why haven't we seen them??? Huh...
For quick grinders/subs, I like Nipmucks/Mucknicks on Rte 20. I can't remember their grinder prices, but know for "regular" groceries they can be sorta pricey.
We also go to Picadilly Pub for a decent dinner that is kid friendly, or to Unos. There's also a Cracker Barrel on Rte 20, not quite as far down as the S&S/Walmart/Uno's plaza. And while some people don't like Rom's, we do eat there once in a while - I think you just have to know what to order, since some of it can be good, some not so good
For kid-geared activities, I'm glad you're planning on going to OSV! (We were married there, so it's a sentimental favorite
: )
There is also a farm that raises beef cattle "naturally" in Brimfield that might be fun for the kids. What is the website again....oh, yes...
RiverRock Farm You can also buy the beef directly from them, not sure on the prices, but imagine it'd be yummy for burgers/steaks!
There's also
Wells State Park if you'd like to do some hiking or something like that.