Mothering Forum banner

Two breastfeeding "myths"?

471 Views 6 Replies 6 Participants Last post by  Mama Poot
Can anyone clarify these questions for me?

1. What's the deal with Vitamin D drops? I've heard that you should give these drops to breastfed babies born in winter months when there isn't much sun since Vit D is not in breastmilk. Is this true, and if so, how do you give them?

2. My mother insists that infants need to be fed water in addition to breastmilk (so they don't dehydrate) since that was the practice back when I was a baby. I've never heard of this being recommended now...anyone else?
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
Exclusive breastfeeding means babies should not have water supplements. There is a ton of water in human milk. Too much water can mean baby doesn't get enough calories, and in severe cases can lead to "water intoxication."

more about this
http://www.kellymom.com/nutrition/so...aby-water.html
Vitamin D
http://www.mothering.com/articles/ne...vitamin-d.html
http://www.kellymom.com/nutrition/vi...vitamin-d.html

The AAP is overreacting in my view by saying all babies should have vitamin D when the risk of rickets is so low, instead of recommending them for certain people. (See links for more info.)
Quote:

Originally Posted by atpeace
Can anyone clarify these questions for me?

1. What's the deal with Vitamin D drops? I've heard that you should give these drops to breastfed babies born in winter months when there isn't much sun since Vit D is not in breastmilk. Is this true, and if so, how do you give them?

2. My mother insists that infants need to be fed water in addition to breastmilk (so they don't dehydrate) since that was the practice back when I was a baby. I've never heard of this being recommended now...anyone else?
1. Some babies with darker skin in areas with limited sun MAY need supplemental vit. D.

2. Totally false.

-Angela
See less See more
no need for water. baby will nurse more on hot days to make up for hydration needs and your milk will also be more "watery" (not the best word, but the most appropriate, probably) to accomodate.

as for vit d drops, i see you are in ontario, canada (according to your location) so depending on how far north you are, you might consider vit d supplements for your baby in the winter months depending on how much sun you are getting. from the research i have read, however, people who live in more northern latitudes have bodies that adapt to vit d storage and usage based on limited sunlight exposure during the winter months. for example, a person living in southern california and used to lots of sunlight throughout the year who then moved to northern canada might have a hard time adjusting the first year or so to the lessened light in the winter months, but a person living in northern canada would store vit d in the body and use it gradually over the months that they have limited sun exposure. also, only 10-15 minutes of sun exposure a week is generally enough to maintain a healthy amount of vit d in the body for the average person.

~claudia
See less See more
Hmmm...DD's pediatrician told me to give DD vitamin D drops but I forget his reasoning. I think I gave them to her once but just felt they didn't seem necessary. Our next appointment he asked if I was giving them to her and I told him no, I always forget to. He said "it's ok, it's not really necessary." I was like "huh?"
:

As far as water, I'm not sure why people think this. My mom especially kept telling me I need to give DD water because she "just HAS to be thirsty" and "how is she supposed to stay hydrated?" I guess my mom thinks breastmilk is powder.
See less See more
Breastmilk is perfect for babies. They don't need anything else until 6 months or later. While the amounts of things like vitamin d and iron are considered "low" in bm, they are more readily absorbed by the baby than artificial drops. My ped wrote me a script for these drops on Monday ( my son isnt even 2 weeks old
) But he is at least 70 and Im not going to change his mind, so I just smiled and thanked him. I don't know if this is true or not, but I read that giving water to a baby under 6 months old is dangerous as it can dilute the blood.
See less See more
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top