Mothering Forum banner
1 - 6 of 6 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Someone showed me this from Dr. Greene (whoever he is). Check out the last paragraph. Is he implying that poor hygiene causes penile cancer and STDs?:

"Sources of childcare information have very different recommendations for care of uncircumcised penises. Some advocate aggressive wiping using cotton swabs and alcohol to clean under the foreskin. At the other extreme, some authorities suggest doing nothing at all until puberty, saying that the collection of cheesy material under the foreskin is natural and desirable. One popular childcare book even differs from itself, saying in a caption, "The uncircumcised penis requires meticulous hygiene; the circumcised penis ... requires no special care," while the accompanying text says, "Contrary to what was once believed, no special care is needed for the uncircumcised penis."

I recommend a more moderate approach.

Structurally, the penis consists of two main parts, the shaft and the head (which is called the glans). Urine and semen exit the body through a tiny opening at the tip of the glans. At birth, the shaft and the glans are covered by a single continuous layer of skin. If circumcision is performed, the part of this skin that covers the glans is cut off. Immediately after circumcision the glans appears swollen, tender, and vivid red, since the foreskin was firmly attached to the glans before it was forcibly separated and then cut off.

In uncircumcised boys, the foreskin at first remains firmly attached to the glans, but gradually over time the attachments are broken (mostly by the stretching resulting from repeated normal erections). In 90% of boys the foreskin is loose and mobile by age 2, but the process can sometimes take five or more years. When the foreskin has separated from the glans, the foreskin can easily be retracted, or pulled back, to leave the glans exposed. Throughout life, a cheesy white material called smegma, consisting primarily of dead skin cells and secretions from sebaceous glands, will accumulate under the foreskin.

In uncircumcised boys, forcibly ripping the foreskin from the glans in the name of hygiene can lead to pain, scarring and adhesions. Do not try to forcibly retract the foreskin or to clean under an adherent foreskin with swabs, antiseptics, or even water. On the other hand, even though doing nothing at all may be considered natural, similar reasoning would lead to not cutting the hair, trimming the nails, washing the hands, or cleaning the bottom after a poop. Gentle hygiene enhances health.

Only the outside of the foreskin needs to be cleaned during the first year. It should be cleaned and bathed with soap and water just like the rest of the diaper area. After his first birthday, you might want to very gently pull back on the skin of the shaft to see if the foreskin retracts. If it doesn't at all, don't worry -- and don't force it! There is certainly no rush. If urine can flow freely, the hole in the foreskin is big enough. As long as the foreskin doesn't easily retract (even in a ten year old), only the outside needs to be washed. If the foreskin retracts a little, it would be okay to gently clean the exposed part of the glans with water (but don't use soap while the foreskin is still partially attached to the glans, since this can irritate this tender area). After cleaning, always pull the foreskin forward to its usual position. This is very important -- otherwise it can get stuck and lead to serious damage.

Once the foreskin has completely separated and retracts freely, begin to teach your son to retract his own foreskin and clean underneath it when he bathes, or at least once a week. For most little boys this personal cleaning will not become a habit unless you encourage it. Mentioning it positively and frequently throughout the years can instill an important sense of responsibility, prevention, and health that will benefit him for years to come.

Your bathtimes together are precious now, but the habits you help your son develop might also reduce sexually transmitted diseases and cancer of the penis (and cervix in his partner) when your little boy becomes a man."
 

· Registered
Joined
·
14,304 Posts
Sure looks like he its
:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
167 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
You know what's funny, though...I was thinking last night that suppose pro-circs really believe that proper hygeine decreases the chance of penile cancer and STDs. Then I say PROBLEM SOLVED. That's two fewer excuses they can use for circumcising.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,914 Posts
Yea, but they are not being logical, so they wouldn't "get" it.

It is funny, because when people bring up the hygeine issue they are really saying that they don't think that THEIR own child will be capable of taking care of their own body.

So for you brave intactivists... or when the person is just beyond help have some fun.

So when you hear the hygeine arguement, have a nice chuckle, stop and say, "so you don't think your son is going to be capable of caring for his own body. Really, we're very confident OUR son(s) (and or daughter(s) can handle the task."

Or pull out, "wow, you must really be scared to have a girl then" or "wow, you must have been really worried about showing your daughter the ropes." "Boys are so easy in comparison."

Or perhaps act concerned and apologize and say that you didn't realize their son was unable to care for himself, has he been diagnosed with something??? Its toeing the line to say this one respectfully.

They won't really get it.

Jessica
 
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top