Mothering Forum banner

soy milk, rice milk or oat milk, which is most nutritious?

  • soya milk

    Votes: 7 43.8%
  • rice milk

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • oat milk

    Votes: 9 56.3%
1 - 20 of 29 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
10,747 Posts
What about hemp milk and coconut milk?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,936 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by kjbrown92 View Post
What about hemp milk and coconut milk?


I wouldn't use any of those except as a limited basis. And I treat them like juice.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,233 Posts
coconut milk is the best! REmember "milks" from anything other than a cow or goat is just the juice extracted from whatever it is, or in the case of grains, it's just a blend of water.

I think it's really a waste of money to actually buy oat milk. Don't you just cook oats in water and blend it? To think of all the packaging and what really is behind it it's one of the things that drives me NUTS about packaged foods! You're basically paying for a tiny amount of something you can buy cheap, and water.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,835 Posts
We like almond milk and hemp milk for our no-dairy child. Soy is bad, never use. With the rice and oat milks, i find they often have bad added oils in them like canola.
Almond milk is just blended almonds, water, salt, vanilla. At least almonds are nutritious, you know?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,183 Posts
First off, what are you looking for? Vitamins/minerals (synthetically added) calcium (added, too)? Is it important to be "like" milk, i.e. for cereal or drinking?

We are big raw goat dairy people in the summer and early fall, but when cold season comes on, we go dairy free. To make up for the nutrients lost, I make loads of bone broth (only chicken so far) and DS (and we) get at least a cup a day, sometimes more, in homemade soup. I think that's the best nutritional replacement for mammal milk (most notably calcium).

If you're veg or need the "milk-like" taste/look, I vote homemade coconut.

Not what you asked, I know, but I personally wouldn't drink/eat or give DS any of those options, esp. store bought with sweeteners, synthetic vitamins, and canola oil.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,437 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Oh.


We use soya milk mostly, and occasionally rice milk.

I haven't seen any coconut milk in the stores, where do you get it? Why is that better than soy, rice, oat milks?

I'm meaning a milk to use for like a substitute for cows milk, for things like a glass of milk to drink, to use for making a milk-shake drink, to make custard and to go on cereal...those types of things.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,233 Posts
If your kids really like something by the glass, that's really the only time I would use rice/oat milk or something if they like it. For baking, smoothies it just seems like a waste. If you think about it, rice milk/oat milk is just the nut, with some water, vanilla maybe, and sweetner. So if you are baking, just use water, with a little extra vanilla or something. For a smoothie, just add water, and extra fruit. If you likle the idea of oat milk, just put a spoon of oats/hot water in blender with a little sweetner and vanilla and blend a minute, and you could use that for the "milk" in baking. It seems expensive to me to spend a couple bucks on something that is pureed rice/oats.

I think almond and coconut milk is the healthiest. I don't always use a ton of canned coconut milk, so when i open the can, I pour it in to ice cube trays and use that as my ice when blending smoothies/shakes. It also makes THE best pudding/ice cream/custards!

The simplest ice cream is a can of coconut milk, a banana, 1/4 good cocoa powder, 1/2 sweetner, 2 tsp vanilla blend in blender until very smooth and freeze. DD actually likes this cold like cold pudding.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,437 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
Quote:

Originally Posted by 425lisamarie View Post
If your kids really like something by the glass, that's really the only time I would use rice/oat milk or something if they like it. For baking, smoothies it just seems like a waste. If you think about it, rice milk/oat milk is just the nut, with some water, vanilla maybe, and sweetner. So if you are baking, just use water, with a little extra vanilla or something. For a smoothie, just add water, and extra fruit. If you likle the idea of oat milk, just put a spoon of oats/hot water in blender with a little sweetner and vanilla and blend a minute, and you could use that for the "milk" in baking. It seems expensive to me to spend a couple bucks on something that is pureed rice/oats.

I think almond and coconut milk is the healthiest. I don't always use a ton of canned coconut milk, so when i open the can, I pour it in to ice cube trays and use that as my ice when blending smoothies/shakes. It also makes THE best pudding/ice cream/custards!

The simplest ice cream is a can of coconut milk, a banana, 1/4 good cocoa powder, 1/2 sweetner, 2 tsp vanilla blend in blender until very smooth and freeze. DD actually likes this cold like cold pudding.
Sounds good. How about for oatmeal, since I usually use soy or rice milk for that, would coconut milk work? Im guessing it would dramatically change the taste, maybe I should switch it to water for that?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
660 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by samy23 View Post
Sounds good. How about for oatmeal, since I usually use soy or rice milk for that, would coconut milk work? Im guessing it would dramatically change the taste, maybe I should switch it to water for that?
We always use water for oatmeal (I've actually never had it with milk). Cook in water and then add some nuts, dried fruit or something else sweet like maple syrup or fruit preserves. That's my favourite way to eat oatmeal.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
993 Posts
I vote for coconut milk. In my grocery store, it's in the International Foods area in metal cans. I get the Thai Kitchen brand.

Coconut milk is great in coffee, for making hot cocoa (I mix it with some water), for custards, for baking. It's very creamy and has tons of nutrition.

Neither soy, nor rice, nor oat milk has much nutrition, and they contain unhealthy components.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
2,909 Posts
How much protein is in coconut milk? I know that soy milk is frowned upon, but I dont know how to get my son protein. He has a bad allergy to eggs, we dont really eat meat, we are dairy free. We've tried quinoa, he wont touch it. So, I at least know protein is in the soy milk. I know he doesnt need loads of protein, but his diet is egg, dairy, peanut, tree nut, fish, and shellfish free. He is small, so I get very paranoid about stuff like protein. I do use sunflower butter, but he only eats it on occasion. Should I just start looking more to coconut milk for his daiy needs? We do it for some baking and ice cream. I like the idea of freezing it for smoothies and stuff. Tomorrow we are icing cookies with it.

I want to add that my son doesnt drink soy milk, like by the cup or anything. He has cereal in it 2-3 days a week. I also will bake with it, like muffins.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
42,757 Posts
I use coconut milk and I like almond milk on cereal


I think soy is ok now and then but I wouldn't make it a regular part of a diet unless it was necessary. If other choices were available I would probably use those first.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
42,757 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by matey View Post
How much protein is in coconut milk? I know that soy milk is frowned upon, but I dont know how to get my son protein. He has a bad allergy to eggs, we dont really eat meat, we are dairy free. We've tried quinoa, he wont touch it. So, I at least know protein is in the soy milk. I know he doesnt need loads of protein, but his diet is egg, dairy, peanut, tree nut, fish, and shellfish free. He is small, so I get very paranoid about stuff like protein. I do use sunflower butter, but he only eats it on occasion. Should I just start looking more to coconut milk for his daiy needs? We do it for some baking and ice cream. I like the idea of freezing it for smoothies and stuff. Tomorrow we are icing cookies with it.
Does your ds eat beans? Mine LOVES beans and hummus.
there are a lot of other sources like whole grains and veggie proteins.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
556 Posts
Haven't read PP, sorry, just wanted to post quickly. We use almond milk - soya milk really is a "treat" food, and unfermented soy products should be used minimally, just once or so a week!

Hemp milk is wonderful, as well as rice. I believe out of the poll options that oat milk would be the most nutritious - but not if it was home-made. Store-bought non-dairy milks are usually fortified with lots of nutrients that are easily absorbed.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
2,909 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by abimommy View Post
Does your ds eat beans? Mine LOVES beans and hummus.

Sorry we cross posted. Yes, he does it beans. He actually loves beans. So, I know that is something.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
42,757 Posts
Quote:

Originally Posted by matey View Post
Sorry we cross posted. Yes, he does it beans. He actually loves beans. So, I know that is something.

Coconut milk doesn't have a lot of protein. Soy milk has more so if you struggle to find protein then you should probably stick to it. There are other whole grains with it like brown rice and such and then veggies and fruit have those types of protein.

I don't eat dairy because I am allergic to it but I do give cheese and yogurt to my ds.

I have seen some studies about soy affecting hormones in boys, but I think that is one of those things that is really a personal decision.

You need to make the choice that is right for your family and your needs.
 
1 - 20 of 29 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top